Re:The AI boss that deploys Hong Kong's subway engineers
by ars on Sunday July 06, 2014 @06:27PM
(#7996127)
> conclude that Intelligence does not exist
You are going about it backwards. Intelligence obviously does exist, yet when we try to figure out what makes it tick each step seems banal.
Your conclusion is that intelligence might not exist, mine is that defining intelligence by the parts that make it up is incorrect. Intelligence is some sort of super-process that is not so easy to break down.
It's like how we share 98% of DNA with an ape - so clearly there is only a 2% difference. Except not. There is a huge difference, an unmeasurable difference, which means that classifying DNA by percent similarity in base pairs is an incorrect approach.
More seriously, your point is common and valid. My own belief however, is that whatever it is that underlies our ability; it will be some mish of deduction, abduction, optimization and search. The application of search/optimization towards the fulfillment of some goal should count as intelligence. But I understand why this view might not (yet) be widely held. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AI_effect