Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by Fomite on Friday July 04, 2014 @06:38PM
(#7990435)
It's hard to select against a cultural practice, generally, as there aren't large numbers of possible phenotypes in the area, and it only matters if that cultural practice results in less children. Dying isn't selected against on its own.
Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by sliverstorm on Sunday July 06, 2014 @01:30PM
(#7995059)
It weakens the community. I was thinking of selection on a community (or higher) level, e.g. a community that has different practices will be stronger and either outlast or conquer the community with dangerous traditions.
Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by Fomite on Sunday July 06, 2014 @06:46PM
(#7996171)
It takes catastrophic levels of disease (think: Smallpox introduction into the entirely susceptible North and South American populations) to sufficiently weaken a culture to the point of conquerability.
Consider the number of European nations in the middle ages fully capable of going to war with high endemic disease levels, or indeed lasting on the field while there were ongoing epidemics in their armies.
Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by emiliobumachar on Friday July 04, 2014 @06:26PM
(#7990401)
Human culture changes way too fast for evolution to act.
Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by nhaehnle on Friday July 04, 2014 @09:19PM
(#7990749)
I have no idea why you were down-voted. It's true: even if, somehow, evolution had managed to at some point kill off all cultures with a certain trait, the same trait is likely to develop again in at most a few centuries.
If somebody has solid arguments against emiliobumachar's point, I'd be interested to hear them.
Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by marcosdumay on Friday July 04, 2014 @10:58PM
(#7990887)
Maybe the downvote was because it isn't completely true. Nothing can be too fast, or too slow for evolution.
It's only that culture evolves by different means than genotipes, and by those means fitting the norm more than compensates any unfitness caused by health problems. At least at the short term.
Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by andrewflnr on Saturday July 05, 2014 @12:53AM
(#7991072)
On the contrary, I would say that evolution works pretty quickly to weed out cultural phenomena like, say, suicide cults, in much the same way that it works quickly to remove gross physical deformities.
Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by DanBC on Saturday July 05, 2014 @05:26AM
(#7991438)
Eating corpses seems to be selected out with diseases like Kuru.
http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kuru_(disease)
That's is rather more contact with a corpse than most funeral practices involve.
Re:Could The Ebola Outbreak Spread To Europe Or The U.S.?
by andrewflnr on Saturday July 05, 2014 @12:51AM
(#7991068)
Not necessarily. In the vast majority of cases, being in close contact with a corpse, before it's gotten serious about decomposing, is not a big deal. I would guess the few cases where it is a problem are not enough to exert significant selection pressure.
You would think this would have been selected against ages ago.