It's probably just me being crazy but I feel like for Mr. Sprey has ulterior motives and reasons beyond the ones he says for hating the F-35, like the fact that he seems to exclusively compare it to planes that he had a hand in creating, and like most people would, claims that his products are exclusively better. I'd say he is quite biased.
Its heavy jump jets make it slow and unmaneuverable, making it a terrible fighter. They also destroy asphalt roads with their heat.
It's a terrible bomber because a) stealth dictates that it can't hold bombs on the underside of the wing and b) the payload space in the center of the aircraft is taken up by a massive jump jet.
This plane is the definition of "jack of all trades, master of none".
https://medium.com/war-is-boring/fd-how-the-u-s-and-its-alli...
The F-35 will never come close to the ground-support capability of the A-10. It will never have the aerobatic ability of a plane a fraction of its weight like a MiG. It will never, ever have the ridiculous durability of an F-15.
At best it will be "adequate" in all roles, never excel. There's a lot of reason for outrage against the recent developments, and Mr. Sprey, like it or not, was responsible for some of the best planes in the world at the time they were released.
Now there's the F-22, which is ambitious but unremarkable, the F-117, basically useless, and now the F-35, a giant turkey of a plane that is possibly a decade away from being ready for combat.
For an example of programs gone awry, look at the Osprey. It's a "helicopter plane" which is not very good in either role.