Re:Qualcomm issues DMCA takedowns for 116 GitHub repositorie...
by mjg59 on Friday July 04, 2014 @12:15AM
(#7987303)
No. All I lose by not following 512(g)(2) is the protections that 512(g)(1) gives me, which are entirely limited to being sued over having taken down the material - eg, the customer suffers financial harm as a result of their website being unavailable, but can't sue me because I followed the terms of 512(g). The protection I have from the copyright holder suing me is under 512(c)(1). The 512(c)(1) protections are not conditional upon 512(g) at all.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Qualcomm issues DMCA takedowns for 116 GitHub repositorie...
by joshuak on Friday July 04, 2014 @03:40PM
(#7990012)
As I've said elsewhere I disagree with this position. And at the risk of beating a dead horse the text specifically says in various ways, and in various places the general concept that a service provider shall not be liable only if a number of general principals are followed that include the fact they are not participating in the selection process of the material. If they begin to participate they are not protected under Safe Harbor.
For example 512 requires that: "the transmission, routing, provision of connections, or storage is carried out through an automatic technical process without selection of the material by the service provider"
Demonstrable proof of non automated selection such as failure to comply with a lawful counter-notice voids the ENTIRE protection.
Companies such as Vimeo have lost protections under the DMCA safe harbor provisions for exactly this reason.