News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NSA targets the privacy-conscious by sliverstorm on Thursday July 03, 2014 @04:21PM (#7985512)
Only as good as the inputs, yes. But if it's a halfway decent filter, it will include machine learning, e.g. a Bayesian filter, and if "is Muslim" turns out to have low correspondence with actual criminal activity that input will quickly be deweighted. Or perhaps paired with other aspects- e.g., perhaps "is Muslim" is of no consequence and "Googles Jihad" is also of no consequence, but "is Muslim" && "Googles Jihad" gives you a point. Just as one example of the patterns a good filter could recognize.

Machines can't be racist, so the arrest score going after lots of poor, Black men must mean that there's something to it.

If a learning Bayesian filter targets a certain demographic, there probably IS something to it.

That really would be amusing/pleasing, if all this work we've spent developing spam filters became the lead-up to an accurate, learning crime filter. Perhaps the fork to spamassassin will be known as crimeassassin?

Re:NSA targets the privacy-conscious by pyre on Thursday July 03, 2014 @09:30PM (#7986814)
> If a learning Bayesian filter targets a certain demographic, there probably IS something to it.

I'm pretty sure both Bayes and Laplace would not agree with the categorization of Bayesian probability as some sort of panacea for determining truth in criminal matters.

Re:NSA targets the privacy-conscious by sliverstorm on Thursday July 03, 2014 @10:39PM (#7987023)
Yes, it is just probability and not truth. But an arrest is often a "guess" with some degree of confidence, not absolute certainty. Thus is a "weight" or "probability" not perfectly applicable?

Trials & convictions is a different matter, more suited to truth-seeking.

Re:NSA targets the privacy-conscious by pyre on Friday July 04, 2014 @09:59AM (#7988729)
Don't disregard the effects that 'just an arrest' have on people. For example, being arrested for child porn-related charges, but not charged / convicted isn't exactly a no-op.
Re:NSA targets the privacy-conscious by TeMPOraL on Friday July 04, 2014 @08:18AM (#7988453)
Not for determining truth, but the degree of confidence in it, yes. Probability is the tool to get to the truth, if you allow for your information to be incomplete and uncertain.
Re:NSA targets the privacy-conscious by me1010 on Thursday July 03, 2014 @08:26PM (#7986661)
Perhaps you should watch "The Thin Blue Line" a few hundred times... and then repost...

I would be seriously concerned about a Bayesian filter being applied as the sole reason for arrests...