News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inside the libertarian version of Burning Man: Guns, booz... by logfromblammo on Thursday July 03, 2014 @04:19PM (#7985497)
Imagine yourself describing a democratic republic to people that have never heard of one. Now imagine that every one of them, down to the last man, suggests that your system will inevitably result in a zombie apocalypse that destroys every living thing on the planet. Also imagine that certain oddly specific details, such as the color and consistency of the zombie blood, is common across all people you talk to.

That is what libertarians experience whenever they describe libertarianism to non-libertarians. It always ends up with people starving in the streets that don't exist because no one built them.

Your scenario, in which one person buys all the streets and then prevents everyone else from using them at reasonable cost ends with that guy getting his head caved in with a chunk of asphalt dug out of one of his own streets. Rule number one for any civilization, regardless of its form of governance, is to not be an asshole. The release valve for people abusing the system is other people ignoring the system.

If you antagonize everyone, then no one will help you police your many miles of streets, to make sure no one on them has not paid. You have one cop car, but no one pulls over when you flash the lights, and if you try to issue a ticket, people crumple it up and throw it in your face.

This is completely independent of the laws or governance. If you don't help other people, they eventually stop helping you. If you coerce other people by force, eventually they start fighting back.

In reality, most people are not jerks, and road investors will likely find that they could have lost less money by buying a boat. The only profitable roads would be in the commercial districts and the highways, and those would probably make more money on parking, advertising, and rest stops than they ever could from direct charges to businesses and the public. Sensible investors would avoid them like the plague unless they already owned some sort of business related to them. Your city roads will be maintained by McDonald's and Wal-Mart, and your highways by ExxonMobil and Chevron. Major bridges and other large capital investments would have associated tolls.

There are no comments on this comment yet.