Re:Qualcomm issues DMCA takedowns for 116 GitHub repositorie...
by joshuak on Thursday July 03, 2014 @05:16PM
(#7985899)
Yeah this doesn't seem to be done very often. I'm trying to encourage the behavior though because I often see that courts are easily confused by technical issues that are well understood by the community.
This may or may not be such a case, but is calming your code is flawless under penalty of perjury an honest mistake?
Re:Qualcomm issues DMCA takedowns for 116 GitHub repositorie...
by x0x0 on Thursday July 03, 2014 @06:41PM
(#7986322)
to summarize: your argument conflicts with observed reality, but you're nonetheless doubling down on it
find a case, even one, where there has been a significant penalty for incorrectly issuing a dmca request
Re:Qualcomm issues DMCA takedowns for 116 GitHub repositorie...
by joshuak on Thursday July 03, 2014 @07:53PM
(#7986571)
I did not take a position one way or the other on incorrect takedown notices.
I said it is my opinion that we as a technical community should try to help the court. Wether we have before, or wether it was successful or not, doesn't enter into it.
Has this ever been done successfully? I found an example in Disney v. Hotfile[1] but it was eventually settled out of court and not in Hotfile's favour.
An honest mistake shouldn't constitute perjury, but the shotgun approach is not acting in good faith.
[1] https://www.eff.org/cases/disney-v-hotfile