Perhaps. I was younger then and didn't feel comfortable negotiating. I'm better at it now. He even had to explain to me how options worked.
But I learned a lot from working with him and met people that I still keep in contact with. I don't regret my choice to take the offer.
In which they suckered you into a false dilemma. You should always reply to those stupid negotiating tactics with "Both. Higher salary and more options."