True...
> because the exercise of a right--in that case, voting--cannot be taxed.
False.
The Supreme Court struck down poll taxes because "A State's conditioning of the right to vote on the payment of a fee or tax violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Fourteenth Amendment" because "[o]nce the franchise is granted to the electorate, lines which determine who may vote may not be drawn so as to cause invidious discrimination", "[f]ee payments or wealth, like race, creed, or color, are unrelated to the citizen's ability to participate intelligently in the electoral process", and "[t]he interest of the State, when it comes to voting registration, is limited to the fixing of standards related to the applicant's qualifications as a voter", finding that "[t]o introduce wealth or payment of a fee as a measure of a voter's qualifications is to introduce a capricious or irrelevant factor." Harper v. Virginia Bd. of Elections, 383 U.S. 663 (1966)
It did not at any point make the argument that "the exercise of a right cannot be taxed". It only made the argument that poll taxes were an unacceptable burden on the right to vote because they impose a burden on a fundamental right that is not sufficiently justified by any state interest relating to the exercise of that right.
> Sales taxes and income taxes imply that there is no right to engage in voluntary commerce.
No, they don't. The Supreme Court tolerating them when it has struck down poll taxes for the reasons described above indicates that the burden that such taxes pose on the right to voluntary commerce, presuming such a right exists, is not unjustified by legitimate government interests related to commerce, it does not imply that the right does not exist (or even that it is not a fundamental right like voting.)
The SCotUS is not staffed by supermen or gods. We can reason as well as they can, but we are not bound by their tradition or political expedience. We can more safely make decisions that might impede the flow of money into the treasury or even collapse the existing government entirely.
I say that a right cannot be taxed. Any external impediment to the exercise of that right, of which taxation is but one, is an infringement. You can disagree, if you like.
Now, a Supreme Court justice, paid in part by the collection of taxes, would obviously say, "Whoa, now. Let's not be too hasty, there, fella." If I were in that position, I too might want to establish some form of guideline or balancing test, such that the infringement be "in the public interest" and "overtly nondiscriminatory, while still greatly advantaging rich people".
Taxing someone's speech by the word is unethical. Taxing someone's religion by the prayer is unethical. Taxing someone's trade by the amount of coin that changes hands is unethical.
We tolerate some level of unethical behavior in government, but it can go too far. If, for instance, someone raised the income tax rate to 101%, there is nothing inherent to the substance of the law preventing that. But you can be certain that it would go to the SCotUS, and they would find a way to say "you can't go that high" without also saying "you can't have that tax at all." It is very likely that they would carefully avoid establishing anything lower than 101% as an upper limit, thus inviting further decisions for 100% and 99% and so on until everyone got tired of trying the same case repeatedly.
Also, I do allege that voluntary commerce is a basic human right. The ability to buy and sell is a necessary and critical element of participation in civil society, and essential to securing our survival needs. It is derived from and intimately related to the right to own property.
Unless we are communist, and openly disavow any right to own property, I think we can safely presume that we also have the right to buy and sell that property.
But let's not just appeal to authority and let it lie without addressing the substance of the argument.
No, it didn't just not explicitly say that was the reason for its decision, it explicitly said what the reason was, and that wasn't it. So it is a falsehood to claim that the SCOTUS struck down poll taxes for the reason you claim.
> but that doesn't obviate the fact that I am making that argument, absent any appeal to authority, right now.
Okay, fine, you are making the argument, and you are wrong. Exercise of rights can be taxed (whether you are using "can be" in the strict sense of possibility, or in the sense of "consistent with the US Constitution".) You may want to argue that they should not be taxed, but you haven't made that argument.
> The issue was that poll taxes were being used to prevent poor black people from voting, denying their rights.
Not exactly; the issue was that taxation created a differential burden based on wealth which thereby denied equal protection of the laws by imposing a qualification with differential impact on an axis (wealth) unrelated to a valid government purpose related to the right being exercised (voting). (Not particularly relevant to the immediate discussion, but additionally contrary to your statement, race actually was not a cited factor in the decision, though wealth was analogized to race, creed, and color in the decision.)
> I say that a right cannot be taxed. Any external impediment to the exercise of that right, of which taxation is but one, is an infringement.
If a right were truly absolute then, certainly, by definition any external impediment would be an infringement. The question is whether we should consider "voluntary commercial activity" an absolute right (a category which even most basic rights are not generally held to fall into, as they are not generally, even by people who agree that they are fundamental rights, tend to accept certain external impediments to them as necessary) -- and you have not made any argument for why it should be so. You may consider it to be an axiom, a fundamental, unquestionable value in itself. But if you do, you should just say that and admit that discussion is impossible, not try to reference a Supreme Court decision that does nothing to support your position.
> But let's not just appeal to authority and let it lie without addressing the substance of the argument.
There is no substance to your argument, just an assertion of what is either a conclusion without support or, to you, a basic axiom ("a right can't be taxed") combined with a series of dubious analogies, and waving at inaccurate descriptions of what the Supreme Court has said and your predictions of what the Supreme Court would say in cases that don't clearly relate to the point you are arguing for.
When I say "cannot be taxed", I mean that the taxation destroys its status as a right.
Matters related to the Supreme Court are distracting from the core argument. I withdraw any claims I made regarding the SCotUS. They were only made as a matter of rhetorical convenience.
As a result, this is the argument:
1. A right is any activity that members of a society agree to protect unconditionally. (definition) 2. Therefore, if conditions are placed on an activity, it is not a right. (contraposition) 3. Voluntary commerce is a right. (premise) 4. Taxation represents the addition of a money-based condition to an activity. (premise) 5. Voluntary commerce includes one or more buyers, and one or more sellers, wherein the sellers transfer ownership to a good or provide a service to the buyers, and the buyers transfer ownership of a quantity of trade currency to the sellers. (definition) 6. Sales taxes apply to commercial activity, when the seller transfers ownership of goods or renders service. (by definition) 7. Income taxes apply to commercial activity, when the buyer transfers ownership of trade currency. (by definition) 6. Therefore, if commerce is a right, application of sales or income taxes would destroy its status as such.
The logic is sound, so only the premises are assailable.
I should clarify that when I said "external impediment", I meant that such impediments can only be created by actors with moral agency. If a mountain stands between you and the marketplace, it is not an external impediment to your right to commerce; it just increases your overhead costs. A highwayman that robs, kidnaps, or murders you on your way to the market is, in that he made a choice that ultimately prevented you from trading. I don't know of any more precise term to describe this. Antagonism, perhaps?
The SCotUS struck down poll taxes because the exercise of a right--in that case, voting--cannot be taxed. By that reasoning, if you support a tax on something, you must believe that no one has a right to that thing.
Sales taxes and income taxes imply that there is no right to engage in voluntary commerce. You have no right to earn or spend money. Property taxes imply you have no right to own property. Naturally, if this principle were carried out to its logical extreme, the government has a revenue incentive in denying people their rights.
And that leads to the question: so how do people who love their freedoms pay for a government? And there is no single, objectively correct answer to that question.
And there is also no good reason to mock and ridicule either the people that ask it, or the people who answer it differently.