News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by rayiner on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @05:18PM (#7979790)
This is pretty much the gist of it. I found this bit annoying:

> We spoke two totally different languages. Mine, the language of reasoned hope and optimism. Theirs, the language of suspicious cynicism, fear and ignorance.

It's CPB's job to be cynical. For every "hopeful optimist" there are hundreds of people seeking to abuse the system. It's simply a confusion as to the delegation of power. Even if you're someone in favor of accelerating legal residency for skilled people like the author, you have to acknowledge that that's a plea to be made to the political figures, not to CPB agents.

Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by enraged_camel on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @06:20PM (#7980162)
>>For every "hopeful optimist" there are hundreds of people seeking to abuse the system.

Citation needed.

Seriously, Americans need to stop perceiving foreigners as unwashed masses, most of whom are seeking to abuse the system.

Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by etherael on Thursday July 03, 2014 @12:55AM (#7981506)
Indeed, it's strange looking in from the outside that they consider the country to be so precious in this fashion. I would not go if I were paid a large amount of money to do so, and I have been offered exactly that numerous times, so that's not just hyperbole either.

The US is not a shining city on the hill, it is a slowly sinking empire with walls made of disjointed, often incoherent words, that even the people charged with enforcing the measures extrapolated therein don't actually understand letalone hope to reasonably enforce.

Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by smm2000 on Thursday July 03, 2014 @03:42AM (#7981971)
15 million illegal immigrants are a damn good reason to perceive foreigners as unwashed masses seeking to abuse the system.
Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by enraged_camel on Thursday July 03, 2014 @01:09PM (#7984302)
But most of those immigrants are sneaking into or being smuggled into the country, as opposed to trying to cheat their way through immigration and border security. The former involves a backpacking trek through the desert whereas the latter involves years if not decades of expensive, arduous bureaucracy.
Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by smm2000 on Thursday July 03, 2014 @03:12PM (#7985035)
Around 40% of illegal immigrants in US had valid visa when they initially entered the country but overstayed. Also significant number of people came into US on tourist visa but then exploited the system to change status through genuine or fake marriage to USC, asylum, study, etc.

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142412788732391630...

Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by enraged_camel on Friday July 04, 2014 @10:28AM (#7988835)
How does changing status via genuine marriage count as "exploiting" the system?
Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by smm2000 on Friday July 04, 2014 @03:59PM (#7990061)
Technically if you get married or plan to get married you are supposed to leave the country and get either fiancee visa or immigrant visa by applying at the consulate abroad. Many (most) people ignore this rule because there is no penalty and many immigration violation (like visa overstay) are waived if you get married to US citizen and change status inside US. You can also appeal immigration decisions. On the other hand if you leave the country with visa overstay, you can be banned for three or ten years from getting any type of visa (even marriage-based one) and the right to appeal is pretty much non-existent.

Overall immigration law is illogical mess with conflicting rules that can often be exploited if you have money and a good lawyer. But even with a good lawyer the system can fuck you over as in the case of that woman.

Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by cryptophile on Thursday July 03, 2014 @04:02AM (#7982021)
They may not have a choice. I can perfectly well see why they erect barriers and put large obstacles in front of people trying to cross their borders. The problem is rather that startups should not demand that you physically move over there. I have had the case several times and I had to refuse the project. Moving over there, is unpractical. Why not collaborate remotely with people around the world? Do people really need to sit next to you in order to work with them?
Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by Taniwha on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @05:22PM (#7979818)
I disagree, large portions of the people traveling through airports are hopeful optimists going on vacation, honest ordinary people trying to play by complex, impenetrable rules, few of them are trying to game the system.

The real problem is the enormous numbers of false positives and the results on the unwitting victims

Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by rayiner on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @05:35PM (#7979891)
Was this a false positive?
Re:Are We Welcome Entrepreneurs or Unwanted Criminals? by Taniwha on Wednesday July 02, 2014 @07:05PM (#7980405)
I was thinking more of all the people who go through this because the US has NO formal emmigration procedure - in any other country you pass through a desk with a customs agent who puts a stamp in your passport saying you have left the country - in NZ, my country, they wont let you leave if you have outstanding fines or warrants.

In the US there is none of this, you just roll up to the gate, it used to depend of some airline minimum wage check in people tearing little green cards out of your passport and them getting to the right government person who typed them in correctly - lots of times it didn't work correctly and people would attempt to come back into the US a second time and then get tossed out because they had "overstayed" their previous visa. A number of friends have been through this insanity.

Now days the US does this electronically some how, it seems more reliable (hopefully) - but is still completely out of the control of the traveler and it still leaves one without a receipt, a stamp in their passport, indicating they have left correctly under the terms of their visa