Re:The Curse of Smart People
by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday July 01, 2014 @08:56AM
(#7970326)
Ok, now here's a question: are there any textbooks introducing model theory and talking about these sorts of topics that don't rely on preexisting knowledge of abstract algebra? Not that I don't want to learn abstract algebra, but I don't even know a good textbook to start that from.
You're right that there are "larger" theories that can prove the consistency of PA, e.g. PA + existence of a large cardinal proves the consistency of PA. But, per Gödel, no consistent axiom system large enough to contain PA can prove its own consistency. This is probably a lot less bad than it sounds though; after all, if we have some unknown axiom system T, and we have a proof in T that T is consistent, does that really tell us anything? Because if T isn't consistent, then it can prove anything, including that T is consistent.