As long as passwords are stored in the system's secure keychain, using passwords is not just OK -- it's the right desktop/mobile UX.
The only time OAuth makes sense is on the web, where by the very nature of the web's design, user's passwords would be provided to unrelated 3rd party servers outside the user's control.
Please STOP inflicting OAuth on non-web platform's users.
EDIT: I misunderstood the complaint! I thought that they wanted to login using a Google account or something similar rather than having a place in Hype Machine to allow Plug to connect and use a token to pass the permission to the program. Oops! I completely agree with the poster's comment in this case.
The only data we store are your username and some basic settings in a .plist (`open ~/Library/Preferences/com.Plug.Plug.plist`) and your token which you can view in Keychain Access.app and search Plug.
I can see from the Hype Machine blog [1] that Plug was developed with the approval and assistance of Hype Machine. Nevertheless, it's unfortunate that the client requires the end user's username and password credentials rather than using an authorization framework like OAuth 2.
[1] http://blog.hypem.com/2014/04/we-are-9/