News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by aphexairlines on Sunday June 29, 2014 @05:50PM (#7962591)
This article is yet another example of how ISP data caps delay or block innovation. If caps were common in the 90s and 2000s, streaming media services that we take for granted today wouldn't have been able to get off the ground.

We have the same problem with LTE networks today. Want to watch a world cup game on your 720p or 1080p smartphone during your commute to the office? One match is probably half of your typical monthly LTE data cap.

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by kylec on Sunday June 29, 2014 @06:26PM (#7962727)
Even without data caps, a TV connected box shouldn't be pulling down hundreds of GB per month while idle. Without data caps the author of this post may not have had an issue, but that still doesn't make what Amazon's doing OK.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by AnthonyMouse on Sunday June 29, 2014 @06:45PM (#7962786)
> Even without data caps, a TV connected box shouldn't be pulling down hundreds of GB per month while idle. Without data caps the author of this post may not have had an issue, but that still doesn't make what Amazon's doing OK.

Amazon is doing exactly what they should be doing. Especially if their box is doing the right thing and downloading the shows in the middle of the night. Comcast et al should be thanking them for this because it moves a huge amount of traffic from peak to off peak and reduces the amount of capacity upgrades they'll need. This is a prime example of why data caps are stupid.

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by karmajunkie on Sunday June 29, 2014 @10:47PM (#7963444)
Ahhh, no. Amazon should not be downloading tens or hundreds of gigs a month without telling me or giving me a way to shut it off. Regardless of your feelings about bandwidth caps, there's plenty of situations that might present a problem with that—shared connections, metered connections, and half a dozen other things i'd rather be doing with my internet connection in the middle of the night than having it download shows my kid watches.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by yoda_sl on Sunday June 29, 2014 @07:14PM (#7962880)
I think both side can be argued. On one hand I really appreciate how quick movies start, and I was initially quite impressed, and like the OP I had to check yesterday my Comcast Internet setting for a different reason: I was quite surprise to see a big jump in my usage. I was planing to start looking at what could be using more bandwidth than usual but thank to the post I know what it is.

At least Amazon should be offering a setting to disable that feature, and whenever someone want to play a movie and the setting is off, then warn the user that he can always turn it back on...

At least in the USA where bandwidth is still limited Amazon should be offering the proper setting for the user to decide. [edit: fixing typo]

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by bitJericho on Monday June 30, 2014 @08:28AM (#7964688)
Spotify allows me to cache what I like for future playback without streaming. It does that by placing me in control.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by aroch on Sunday June 29, 2014 @06:30PM (#7962732)
It only has 8GB of onboard storage, what the hell is it downloading and what is is doing with all that downloaded data?
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by rgbrgb on Sunday June 29, 2014 @06:43PM (#7962780)
It's preemptively buffering video streams.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by johansch on Sunday June 29, 2014 @07:31PM (#7962926)
At 80 GB/day? It would have to fill the flash memory 10x over in a day.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by danudey on Sunday June 29, 2014 @07:51PM (#7962971)
It could easily be a software bug.

1. Pre-cache TV show A

2. Local store full

3. Delete TV show A

4. Pre-cache TV show B

etc

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by adolph on Sunday June 29, 2014 @08:22PM (#7963060)
Never ascribe to nefarious intent that which may be a software bug/feature.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by Steko on Monday June 30, 2014 @04:57AM (#7964246)
It probably caches the first minute of hundreds of shows since those are the pain points in streaming services.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by Touche on Monday June 30, 2014 @08:48AM (#7964747)
I feel like this might be it. With the Fire TV when you select to watch something it starts instantly, no matter if it is a show that you watched the previous episode or a random movie you picked out on the spot. I think it's caching everything that is visible from the homescreen, at least.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by amalag on Monday June 30, 2014 @11:05AM (#7965403)
Yes this has to be a bug, I don't think they planned on downloading 80Gb/day and the bandwidth cap is not relevant. Unless they have a terrabyte HD they plan on keeping full there is no reason to download that much.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by mythealias on Sunday June 29, 2014 @09:30PM (#7963222)
jun 7 and 8 happen to be sat & sun. so it is possible the author was browsing different shows and the tv trying to keep up with it.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by randomfool on Sunday June 29, 2014 @10:59PM (#7963482)
Given a choice between unlimited data or net neutrality, I would choose net neutrality. The argument behind 'fast lanes' is that netflix et al need to pay for bandwidth while we are just paying for access. I would much rather pay a metered rate and have it clear that the ISP should not interfere.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by randomfool on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:23AM (#7963943)
The thing that I fear though, is that broadband monopolists would use metered service to price gouge high-end users. The lack of competition makes this too easy to exploit.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by Xylakant on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:53AM (#7964016)
But then the problem is lack of competition, not metered usage. Lack of competition also make the net neutrality issue worse, so that would be the right thing to tackle.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by dublinben on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:37AM (#7963975)
The problem with accepting a metered rate is that it is completely divorced from the reality of the costs associated with providing your service. With utilities like gas, electricity, and water, there is a clear marginal cost for every additional unit you consume. This is not true for a unit of 'internet' from your ISP. Their operating costs are sunk and inflexible. Your next bit does not 'cost' them anything to send, so why should you pay for it as if it did?
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by Xylakant on Monday June 30, 2014 @02:49AM (#7964004)
How is it disconnected from the costs of providing the service? This could only be true if all connections were built to support the maximum possible bandwidth all costumers are theoretically capable of. Because otherwise, the price you're charged is a mix-calculation - it's the price that's required to deliver the promised number of bits during a given timeframe.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by PhantomGremlin on Monday June 30, 2014 @12:06AM (#7963649)
> We have the same problem with LTE networks today.

Yes and no. Over the air bandwidth is a very very limited resource to what can be delivered by fiber and coax.

Which means that the only way LTE could be used to send the World Cup to you is by some sort of multicast that would simultaneously send the same content to many smartphones at once. That would be of great interest to many people.

But the laws of physics, as presented by Claude Shannon [1] back in 1948, and building on earlier work by people like Nyquist, say that in a "noisy" channel there is a finite limit to how much data can be sent. That precludes everyone being able to simultaneously receive different content over the "limited spectrum" allocated to LTE.

I say "limited spectrum" because the FCC has been allowing more and more of the old TV spectrum to be used for wireless. But it's still insignificant compared to what can be easily pushed over glass fiber.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noisy-channel_coding_theorem

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by yaeger on Monday June 30, 2014 @03:13AM (#7964074)
Datacaps? When I started internetting the best deal that was available was 100 bucks for 100 hours.

That's right, datacaps wasn't even a concern for ISPs. Mostly because they probably didn't even know how to bill this new fad called the internet. So they did like telcos do. Bill by the minute.

So I literally set a watch next to me to clock how long I was online so I wouldn't go over my limit.

The first time I got an unlimited flatrate, I nearly cried.

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by jhonovich on Sunday June 29, 2014 @07:45PM (#7962957)
"ISP data caps delay or block innovation"

So they should provide totally unlimited data for a fixed price?

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by Spittie on Sunday June 29, 2014 @09:15PM (#7963184)
There is no such thing as "unlimited data", your speed is your cap.

Anyway, it's understandable that your ISP will want to have a talk with you if you push/pull 10+ TB every month (in this case, you're probably violating their "no commercial service on consumer line" rule), but 250GB/month is just ridiculous.

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by Bud on Sunday June 29, 2014 @09:31PM (#7963231)
I can see that you're a bit out of date on these issues, so let me inform you:

1) No, your speed is not your cap. Net providers are increasingly implementing "soft caps" that they don't tell you about when you buy the service. 2) If you think 250GB/month is ridiculously low as a cap, go try to use 10TB a month with most providers and let me know what your results are.

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by thomasvarney723 on Sunday June 29, 2014 @09:07PM (#7963163)
I don't mean to sound like I know the best pricing scheme for ISPs but it has always seemed to me that the pricing model used for home internet makes the most sense. Once you have an infrastructure in place, the cost to send data over it is minimal, right? So, to me, paying for speed instead of an amount of data makes the most sense.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by thefreeman on Monday June 30, 2014 @12:48AM (#7963739)
You are assuming they have the infrastructure to support 100% usage from all customers at all times. They obviously do not. So they try to discourage / limit usage to avoid having to pay for more / newer infrastructure.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by Touche on Monday June 30, 2014 @08:53AM (#7964760)
Why sell bandwidth you don't have? That's dishonest advertising.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by dfox on Sunday June 29, 2014 @09:08PM (#7963165)
They should decide whether they want to bill for X amount of data transfered or X amount of bandwidth and clearly advertise the service as one or other.
Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by philjohn on Monday June 30, 2014 @06:35AM (#7964415)
BT have been able to do this in the UK with their Infinity FTTC service. No small print about "Subject to FUP" - it's really unlimited, and fast (I get 80Mbps down and 19Mbps up).

Checked my bandwidth usage for the last month (we stream the majority of our viewing) and it stands at 955GB. Not so much as a peep from them about it being excessive.

Re:A Problem With Amazon’s Fire TV by richardwhiuk on Sunday June 29, 2014 @08:13PM (#7963040)
No they should be offering it for free, because otherwise they aren't being neutral to all data obviously!