None of the things you mentioned are new.
> Go makes concurrent programming safe and easy
Mutability & concurrency, nils, interface casts -- these things all go against safe.
> Tell me again that there isn't good engineering behind Go.
You seem to think that a language that has baked in syntax for concurrency, or that has famous people behind it necessarily has "good engineering" behind it. I don't understand how one leads to the other.
When so many mistakes and regressions go into a language, one shouldn't care that famous names are behind it.
> Go tackles newer problems in a newer way
Go is essentially Algol 69 with baked in concurrency syntax.
> Tell me again that Go is a regression from other programming languages
Losing null safety, sum types & pattern matching, parameteric polymorphism and type-classes, all form a huge regression in PL design from the state of the art.
You're thinking in terms of "here's this set of bullet point features that I think a language has to have to be a proper, modern language." But the grandparent was asking you to consider that a different set of features might have value form some real-world problems that Go's authors had really bumped into. You reply, "Nope, couldn't have - it doesn't have my bullet point features!"
There are more things in programming than are dreamt of in your philosophy of what a programming language should be.
He said Go makes concurrency safe & easy, when Go emphasizes features that contradict safety and ease.
He said Go tackled problems in a newer way, when Go is really Algol69 + coroutines.
He denied Go regressing from other languages, when it throws away decades of PL research.
In none of this did he say "Here's an alternate set of features that ...". No. He said concrete, specific, wrong things.
What you are saying is a different thing -- and I also disagree with you.
These "bullet list" features weren't invented for the lols. They were created to solve real problems. Problems that Go doesn't have an alternate solution to.
Go programs dereference null. That is a bad thing. Languages with my "bullet point features" do not dereference null.
Go programs duplicate code to handle different types. Ditto.
Go programs can (and thus do!) mutate some data after it was sent to a concurrent goroutine. Ditto.
Go programs can cast down to incorrect types. Ditto.
The "bullet point features" are important. There are alternatives, but Go doesn't sport any of them.
I do agree with the author here: Go the language does nothing new. Go the platform, on the other hand, is a really pleasant new experience when compared with other languages.
The language is a regression in features compared to what other languages can do, but that is totally understandable when you look at what Go is aimed at.
Like putting words into people's mouths as a discussion tactic? You're kidding, right? So it also lacks some not-new "old dependable" gadgets as well. So what? I don't see what point you're making. Did you write that comment just to overlay in indefensible position on me?
As an exercise: Name a language feature Go doesn't have that's newer than generics.
Like putting words into people's mouths as a discussion tactic? You're kidding, right? So it also lacks some not-new "old dependable" gadgets as well. So what?
I love Go, because it fits in my head.
This. I love Go's simplicity. Coming back to Go code I wrote months ago, I can immediately understand what it does virtually every time, which required lots of discipline I didn't always have in other languages. Lots of languages have obscure corners that allow you to do really cool things that aren't obvious, but for the most part, Go doesn't have these; what you see is what's happening.
Are there things that would make Go a better language? Sure! Should the type system be improved? Yup! One thing that makes me cringe is when I open up library code and see interface{} and calls to the reflection package all over the place, but general solutions often require that in Go, and that's a problem. In practice, though, this is almost a feature: if you see that stuff in code you're reading, it's a giant red flag that this code is tricky and possibly slow, and care is needed.
Edit: speeling
I don't think golang invented static linking. ;)
Go does, however, have a very pragmatic feel to it. The creators, in general, seem to take a very measured look at things before adding them, and are very careful to keep the compatibility promise for 1.x. The overall result feels very "engineered" (especially when using the tooling).
Go clearly isn't perfect, but yet it feels rather robust for such a young language.
The author's conclusion:
is hardly sustainable. Go was production-ready in 2011 with a stable version 1.0. It has a surprisingly mature tool chain and vibrant community. Go cross-compiles from my 64-bit Mac to a 32-bit Raspberry Pi or ARM Android phone on a whim. I can deploy my app by copying a single, self-contained binary. Tell me again that Go does nothing new for us.Go makes concurrent programming safe and easy (with a nice syntax) -- something that we frankly should have done 30-40 years ago when we first started thinking about multiprocessing. Go was invented by folks like Ken Thompson (who created Unix) and Rob Pike (who created the Plan 9 operating system and co-created UTF-8). Tell me again that there isn't good engineering behind Go.
Finally, Go attacks the needs of modern programming from a different paradigm than we have been using for the last 10-20 years. From the first paragraph of Effective Go:
> ... thinking about the problem from a Go perspective could produce a successful but quite different program. In other words, to write Go well, it's important to understand its properties and idioms.
So of course it's different than a lot of other aged languages. Go tackles newer problems in a newer way. Tell me again that Go is a regression from other programming languages.