I prefer the pg explanation - the reason we have messed up teenagers is they don't have any life direction or things to do.
I was speaking to a relative recently who just made it out of the teenage years. He is completely normal in every respect - doing well with his education, socially well adjusted, healthy, polite. But he had purpose and direction to his life very early on - learned to fly at age 16, got a part time job at 17, had specific interests that he pursued. He mostly ignored trying to fit into the social teenage life and this seems to have been a useful hack in getting around wasting time being an emotional wreck.
I think give any teen a direction - even if it is front-line infantry - and they don't develop the neurotic self obsession that is common.
Perhaps the reasons that young adults are enlisted in armies and for other risky activitys is precisely because they lack the experience to judge risk well, and because societies have found providing them regimented direction is better than leaving them idle?
Anecdotally that at least seems to support your theory.
"You may wonder why, if adolescents have such enhanced capacity for anxiety, they are such novelty seekers and risk takers. It would seem that the two traits are at odds. The answer, in part, is that the brain’s reward center, just like its fear circuit, matures earlier than the prefrontal cortex. That reward center drives much of teenagers’ risky behavior. This behavioral paradox also helps explain why adolescents are particularly prone to injury and trauma. The top three killers of teenagers are accidents, homicide and suicide."
That's what basic training is for. That, and developing unit cohesion.
Everyone gets paralyzed by terror when the guns start firing. You work through that with desensitization. Part of the training is being shot at by blanks. Young people are recruited because of the items Swizec listed, not because of some magic brain wiring they have at that age.
If you don't work through it, you get dead. Which is roughly how firefights between untrained gang members shape up. They freeze up and get shot. Bystanders freeze up and take a stray bullet. As simple as that. That's the fundamental difference between a trained and untrained gunman.
Glory of battle. Glory of startups. Glory of anything. Give me a 20 year old male and some cultural pressure, and I will make you a blind follower of anything.
Back then it was to be called brave, death wasn't as scary as it is now. Now, we all want to lead long lives and so the things that scare us now are different from what scared them earlier.
1.
> The amygdala — is precocious and develops way ahead of the prefrontal cortex
2. > the brain’s reward center, just like its fear circuit, matures earlier than the prefrontal cortex
I had a quick Google but couldn't really find any satisfactory research that would support this. Anyone have any papers? What does "mature" really mean in this context, how is it being measured?
As far as I can tell, the concept of the hormone-crazed teenager is coeval with suburbia. I don't think this is a coincidence. I think teenagers are driven crazy by the life they're made to lead. Teenage apprentices in the Renaissance were working dogs. Teenagers now are neurotic lapdogs. Their craziness is the craziness of the idle everywhere."
http://www.paulgraham.com/nerds.html
"Largely because of a quirk of brain development, adolescents, on average, experience more anxiety and fear and have a harder time learning how not to be afraid than either children or adults."
This doesn't pass the smell test. Historically, in every culture, young adults (and especially young men) have always been the big risk-takers; from moving to a new country, to dealing drugs, to enlisting in the army, to killing oneself for Allah.