Re:Depression is not a malfunction
by timr on Monday August 31, 2009 @12:30PM
(#796216)
"There is a productive emotion that causes both reflectiveness and social isolation; it's called "sadness". People often describe a period of mourning as a necessary downtime, a reconfiguration, to get ready for the rest of one's life. I have never heard anyone describe depression as anything other than a waste of time."
What the article is trying to describe is the theory that the neural mechanisms that enable reflectiveness are also responsible for depression; the theory argues that the former trait presents a selective advantage, but that defects in the process result in depression.
Neither the theory nor the article (in my reading) are arguing that depression is a beneficial outcome -- only that depression may be an inevitable, occasional result of having the capacity for reflectivity and sadness. It's a hypothesis for why depression isn't more rare than it is.
What the article is trying to describe is the theory that the neural mechanisms that enable reflectiveness are also responsible for depression; the theory argues that the former trait presents a selective advantage, but that defects in the process result in depression.
Neither the theory nor the article (in my reading) are arguing that depression is a beneficial outcome -- only that depression may be an inevitable, occasional result of having the capacity for reflectivity and sadness. It's a hypothesis for why depression isn't more rare than it is.