Re:The Wu-Tang Clan and The World's Most Exclusive Album
by filearts on Friday June 27, 2014 @03:59PM
(#7956020)
The author builds arguments based on a couple of premises with which I disagree:
1. Live music and recorded music are just two representations of the same underlying piece of art.
I would argue that each rendition of a song is its own piece of artwork. A recording is tweaked until it represents the artist's (or producer's) vision of what the piece should sound like. A live show is spontaneous and unique by definition.
2. The measure of art is defined by the intrinsic quality of the piece.
I think that art is more than the piece itself and includes the context in which it was created and the way it is presented.
In the case of this album, I think that the business model, the current piracy context and even the gilded box contribute to a very interesting piece of artwork. Whether or not the album 'sounds good' is only one piece of the genius of this work.
To say that the Wu-Tang Clan is missing the issue with respect to music's exclusivity is totally beside the point. This is something entirely new, with a powerful statement in a very interesting context. For all we know, the entire album could be a bunch of farm animals and gun shots[1][2] and this would still be a great piece of artwork.
1. Live music and recorded music are just two representations of the same underlying piece of art.
I would argue that each rendition of a song is its own piece of artwork. A recording is tweaked until it represents the artist's (or producer's) vision of what the piece should sound like. A live show is spontaneous and unique by definition.
2. The measure of art is defined by the intrinsic quality of the piece.
I think that art is more than the piece itself and includes the context in which it was created and the way it is presented.
In the case of this album, I think that the business model, the current piracy context and even the gilded box contribute to a very interesting piece of artwork. Whether or not the album 'sounds good' is only one piece of the genius of this work.
To say that the Wu-Tang Clan is missing the issue with respect to music's exclusivity is totally beside the point. This is something entirely new, with a powerful statement in a very interesting context. For all we know, the entire album could be a bunch of farm animals and gun shots[1][2] and this would still be a great piece of artwork.
1: http://www.metafilter.com/73403/Something-Awful-Forum-Hilari...
2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VbZMnF1VNlE