Re:World Cup Follow-Up: Update of Winning Probabilities and ...
by Someone on Friday June 27, 2014 @01:47PM
(#7955264)
This is a different situation.
We have
P(Belgium reaches quarters) >= P(Belgium wins overall)
P(USA reaches quarters) >= P(USA wins overall)
P(USA reaches quarters) >= P(Belgium reaches quarter)
That does not imply P(USA wins overall) >= P(Belgium wins overall)
Re:World Cup Follow-Up: Update of Winning Probabilities and ...
by StavrosK on Friday June 27, 2014 @10:39AM
(#7954104)
The coin won't get any advantage from playing in its home field, for example. I specifically said that I'm not arguing that this is the case here, but one can conceive of an example where it would.
Re:World Cup Follow-Up: Update of Winning Probabilities and ...
by seabee on Friday June 27, 2014 @12:50PM
(#7954929)
I cannot conceive of an example. In fact I argued that it is impossible because of the fundamental rules of conditional probability.
Re:World Cup Follow-Up: Update of Winning Probabilities and ...
by sp332 on Friday June 27, 2014 @01:01PM
(#7954993)
Probability of losing is not transitive. If A is likely to lose to B, and B is likely to lose to C, it does not follow that A is likely to lose to C.
Re:World Cup Follow-Up: Update of Winning Probabilities and ...
by pedrosorio on Friday June 27, 2014 @01:40PM
(#7955224)
Unless we're using ELO to determine these probabilities.
As such, there is no way the probability of winning can exceed the probability of reaching the quarter finals.