I think how successful a model is depends on your purpose too - if you have a model that predicts only 60% of games correctly, while technically you're not very "good", you're doing much better than those gambling on the sport (usually the favorite in sports betting wins at a rate of 52-54% I think) or probably conventional 'sports analysts' (no data to support the second point, that's an educated guess based on the gambling statistic).
http://blog.wolfram.com/2014/06/20/predicting-who-will-win-t...
Just goes to show, when it comes to sport, you can throw away most of these models until they start taking into account news and gossip from tabloids which probably has more bearing on team performance than raw numbers.
Someone would bet Argentina #2 if the have faith Messi will play what he's used to, or Netherlands if they consider the actual performance in this cup. This reflects 538's stronger bias for player skill score, while Wolfram seems to adjust more for the past results.
Brazil: 24.2% Germany: 23.0% Netherlands: 19.0% Argentina: 15.7%
#1
* 538 - Brazil - 36.0%
* WOLF - Brazil - 32.2%
#2
* 538 - Argentina - 17.0%
* WOLF - Netherlands - 23.5%
#3
* 538 - Germany - 12.0%
* WOLF - Germany - 21.6%
This paints a pretty interesting picture about trying to use statistics and math to predict sporting tournaments like this. Seems like nobody has been very successful at this yet. Obviously it gets "easier" as the tournament progresses, though.
* [1] http://fivethirtyeight.com/interactives/world-cup/