You could also have a little script that does something like:
# Usage gbisect_prs bad good
git bisect start
for commit in "git log --since good --until bad"
if not commit.message.startswith("Merge pull request #"):
git bisect skip commit.hash
Turned into real code, obviously, but it'd tell git to ignore any commit that's not a PR merge.You could also just include this into your bisect script if you're not doing it by hand, return 125 if it's not a commit you want to test.
In a sense I work this way, without the squashing. When I write a test, the build fails and nothing has been done on the application codebase so I don't commit. When I fix the build by writing new code, I commit.
Maybe I should be doing small intermediate commits and squashing the commits into one commit.
I would recommend trying that, or at least something similar: Try committing regularly (this is useful if you ever want to go back to a prior state while working or e.g. pick up where you left off on a different machine, etc), but reorganizing and cleaning up your topic branch (via rebase -i, etc.) into a few commits before merging (fast forward). What is "a few commits"? Well, it's a bit of a judgement call, but I just group stuff into logicially coherent units which make sense as single units of functionality. Of course you must make sure each individual commit at least builds sensibly and preferably that all tests run too.
> The commit you end up with or N prior commits which don't build (and which is incidentally usually full of "noise").
The alternative, where things are squashed together, would leave you with just one commit but it'd be those N combined together (at least, it could well be more).
Well, if you're going to be bisecting a lot or compilation takes a while, it saves you time to do the squash now (when you know which commits are supposed to compile and which aren't) rather than when you come back to it.