It didn't seem to be a big deal. Nor should it be -- the goal of your interviewer is to watch you do things like: test your code, remember to check the edge cases, manipulate pointers correctly, be able to figure out how your brain-dead bubblesort algorithm is likely to scale as N grows larger, knowing what exceptions are and understanding their proper role...
It's possible that the interview is better if you're missing your higher brain functions while you're writing the demo code. You're trying to demonstrate your everyday habits, the things you do instinctively, when your memory, your cram session, and Stack Overflow all fail you. It's like asking a trumpeter to pick up their instrument and blow a few notes: according to Malcolm Gladwell, some orchestra conductors claim to be able to detect expert players with nothing more than this one test.
ADDENDUM: Oh, look, Reg Braithwaite already said this, more or less:
http://weblog.raganwald.com/2007/01/dont-overthink-fizzbuzz....
But now that I started my own company, I get paid a little more than a guy of my age/qualifications should. Hopefully soon a lot more if I can keep building it up. I get paid based on the economic value of my products, not what any one individual thinks of me personally.