Re:Show HN: Replace CAPTCHA with Proof-of-Work
by singlow on Wednesday June 25, 2014 @01:33PM
(#7945483)
If the workload is made to be very large, say 30 seconds on a recent desktop, it could fall back to a captcha for slower devices. At least people visiting with fast computers could be spared the captcha.
If you don't want to annoy your visitors you're going to need to have the max runtime on any device at around 25 seconds.
Now you can't scale this per device, because you can't rule out devices spoofing what they are. So this means you're looking at barely a few seconds to break it on any sort of desktop hardware, and even less on any dedicated server.
Spammers are probably waiting longer than that to just load the page they want to spam, so it wont slow them down. For this to work you need to solve this issue, and I hope you can, but I don't see how.