There's still an opportunity cost. Would they prefer to hit a service which limits their machines to a few thousand attempts per day, or a service which does not and lets them put through several million attempts per day?
> Even I don't pay for CPU load on my VPS.
Perhaps not, but it sets a hard limit on how much you can do in a given time period.
> That's really expensive because it's real money.
If they're stealing computer time via a botnet, they're probably not going to be paying Amazon Turk with their own credit card.
This could be used by those downloader sites that make users wait.
Botnets may not have a marginal cost, but they still have a limited supply, and a demand for their use, which determined the cost to consumers. If they are less effective per time on spamming, either the cost of spamming will increase, or botnet operators will shift into other more profitable verticals.
So the user enters the CAPTCHA, then some other botted computer enters it in the real webform.
Basically these types of measures are stupid because any virused computer can be made to do them anyway this is why CAPTCHAs are only 70 cents / 1000, it isn't because people in India are lining up to enter CAPTCHAs at an Indian minimum wage.
At the very least, you can replace all ads on the Web with ads you make money from. And/or you could phish users and steal e-mail/bank passwords. And/or you could replace binaries the user tries to download with malicious ones.
And so on. I suspect captchas are pretty far down on the list of things you'd do if you had this capability. :)
Why is that a good thing?
Showing a captcha each time, for a repetitive task would be a horrible UX decision.
Letting my mind go wild and wondering whether it would make sense to let visitors actually pay for the login. This could be DOGE-Coins for example. One could set up a DOGE-faucet and give back the WOWness.
Is that idea totally dumb or does it make any sense? Would love to read your opinion.
- Botnet operations are hacked PCs. They aren't paying for CPU time.
- Low-rent spammers often use hacked or rented servers. They aren't paying for CPU time.
- Even I don't pay for CPU load on my VPS.
This won't stop spam. Simple as that. You might get money from this but you're also going to keep getting spam. Oh and you'll chronically annoy everybody on a slow computer who doesn't want to wait.
Compare it to this $0.70/1000 for CAPTCHAs. That's really expensive because it's real money. It also takes time. It also doesn't guarantee posting (many sites have secondary spam-detection features) which might mean 90% are insta-deleted, 5% are held for moderation and only 5% make it through. $0.014/post is actually pretty expensive. Much more than they're spending to get past you.