Re:Why Being an Australian Startup Sucks
by femto on Tuesday June 24, 2014 @11:21PM
(#7942082)
Here's an alternative view: As collective safety nets (unemployment benefits, public housing, Medicare, ..) are removed in the name of lower taxes, it becomes much riskier to strike out on a new venture. With collective safety nets, you can take a risk and know that in the worst case you will have food, shelter and health. Without the safety nets, you stand to loose everything. I'd argue that a reasonable level of tax is a subsidy to founders and a promoter of start-ups.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Couldn't such a system be built voluntarily? Why should a startup founder be able to bet on someone else's money?
If there is a group of people who need those benefits they can pool money by themselves and provide a safety net for members of that group.
> Couldn't such a system be built voluntarily?
Yes, but would it be as effective as a universal scheme? Also, there is a chicken and egg situation, whereby only people with the advantage of enough wealth to join in the voluntary scheme could access a safety net, biasing against people who do not have advantage but do have the ability to contribute.
> Why should a startup founder be able to bet on someone else's money?
Because we're all linked by, and benefit from, our societal connections and as a society we've collectively decided that it's the best way forward.
---
Edit: grammar
Every system has its own set of drawbacks. A non-voluntary system has the drawback of forcefully extorting money from people with proven capability[1] and then handing it over to possibly incapable / lazy people.
[1]: Assuming an uncorrupted system. Else, all systems are equally bad.