Re:Why C++ Sails When the Vasa Sank [pdf]
by AnimalMuppet on Monday June 23, 2014 @07:18PM
(#7935370)
Well, if one is frustrated with the limitations of a particular tool, learning other tools that are like it may in fact help - if the other tools work around some of the frustrations. If not, then it's a waste of time.
The value proposition of Rust is unique, at least when compared to the languages that you've brought up (and C++).
And how are Rust and Go "mostly the same"?
Re:Why C++ Sails When the Vasa Sank [pdf]
by steveklabnik on Monday June 23, 2014 @07:21PM
(#7935377)
Well, it depends on how you weight the alternatives. Rust's advantage over C++ is its memory safety. Go is similar (I'm not sure if its safety guarantees are as strong as Rust, I should read up on that...), and it's advantage over Rust is that its type system is easier to get started with, but its disadvantage is requiring garbage collection. D is closer to C++ than Rust is, but has amazing metaprogramming, and defaults to GC, though it's not mandatory.
If none of these things matter to you, then they do seem similar. But if they do matter, then the difference is much larger.
I wish language advocates would break themselves of the urge to sum up languages they don't use.
Re:Why C++ Sails When the Vasa Sank [pdf]
by steveklabnik on Tuesday June 24, 2014 @12:42PM
(#7938705)
I did use D a lot, though it was very long ago. I don't like Go, but I respect quite a bit of it.
I consider myself more of a PLT enthusiast than a language advocate. Is there anything about my summation that's incorrect?
Yes, I think so. Let's not debate it though.
Re:Why C++ Sails When the Vasa Sank [pdf]
by steveklabnik on Tuesday June 24, 2014 @01:02PM
(#7938824)
Yes, let's not. I just highly respect your opinion, and know you have a lot to say about Go.
In fact I find the premise of all the Go/Rust/D advocates a bit strange. It makes sense to learn a tool that does something you can't do with your existing ones, but learning 5 tools that are mostly the same is a waste of time unless one is not into collecting tools as a hobby.