Of course I'm not sure that those factors are enough to completely sink the model, but there certainly are such factors in play.
> The issue (not well articulated in TFA) is that when both Poisson variables are expected to have low counts, it's difficult to distinguish slightly-different per-possession probabilities.
I take this to mean that in a match up between broadly comparable teams, the outcome will be indistinguishable from chance, which most fans would accept as completely fine (and possibly even preferable). I still find it hard to reconcile this with the dominance of a few teams over quite long periods of time in international soccer, even in the presence of relatively low scores although I suppose I would have to do some actual number crunching to tell whether this was relevant or not.
"team of random people...so false it's laughable..." -- Absolutely true. This fallacy is implicit in some of the language in the OP, which, incidentally, seems chosen to goad fans.
But I don't think it's a problem for the model. Basically, there are two per-possession goal probabilities when team A plays team B (call them G_AB and G_BA; they are between 0 and 1).
These numbers are a function of both A and B, because if Team A is really bad, and B is good, then G_AB ("chance A scores on B") will be really low. But if C is just as bad as A, than G_AC will be moderate.
The expected points scored by A is N * G_AB, and by B, N * G_BA. The model allows G_AB << G_BA, and indeed G_BA ~= 1, so then it predicts B will almost always win the game.
Note that the Poisson limit will not apply if G is not pretty low (say, less than 0.1), and you need N moderately high (say, bigger than 10) so that N * G will itself be moderate.
*
The issue (not well articulated in TFA) is that when both Poisson variables are expected to have low counts, it's difficult to distinguish slightly-different per-possession probabilities.