News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is soccer anything more than Poisson noise? by dasil003 on Monday June 23, 2014 @03:09PM (#7933850)
The stats could be really interesting, but the whole opening salvo against sports fandom turned me off to much to continue reading. I don't know if the author believes the ridiculous stereotype that all geeks hate sports and therefore it's okay to make ridiculous unsubstantiated leaps of logic like "attention devoted to the World Cup is founded on flimsy numerology", but it certainly is not a smart thing to say for someone who prides themselves on their logic and critical thinking ability.

The randomness of a football match is no different from the randomness of every day life. People like sports because they identify with the players and their human capabilities. Every moment on the pitch there are 22 people taking action. A football match is not a sequence of random events, but rather the continual human response to a changing situation that each one can affect only in a limited way. When amazing "low-probability" events occur, it's often because of tremendous human skill that anyone who's ever tried to kick a ball can appreciate. If it was robots playing no one would care. The fact that there are upsets and freak occurrences is just another part of what keeps it interesting; absolute pinpointing of the objective "best" team is irrelevant.

Re:Is soccer anything more than Poisson noise? by timr on Monday June 23, 2014 @03:34PM (#7934055)
That's not an "opening salvo" -- that's the thesis of the piece. His contention is that soccer, more than most other sports, is a poisson machine. He goes into the math.

"The randomness of a football match is no different from the randomness of every day life."

Well, no, actually. Some things in life are more random than others. And however skilled they may be, the large number of (fallible) people on the field playing this game certainly doesn't make it less random.

As games go, soccer doesn't have many structural impediments to randomness. We'd (hopefully) feel pretty silly if we got worked up every few years about a global coin-flipping tournament, but, here we are, getting worked up over teams of people engaged in an event where the outcome is dominated by chance.

(And oh, hey: it sort of pegs the irony-o-meter that you're accusing the author of being closed-minded about sports when you can't even be bothered to read an argument because you've decided that you disagree with it in advance. Well played.)

Re:Is soccer anything more than Poisson noise? by dasil003 on Monday June 23, 2014 @04:42PM (#7934520)
Come on now, this entire comment is unfair, it's like you're willfully ignoring my post's actual content in order to grind your own axe:

> That's not an "opening salvo" -- that's the thesis of the piece. His contention is that soccer, more than most other sports, is a poisson machine. He goes into the math.

I don't object to the thesis, I object to the opening salvo.

> Well, no, actually. Some things in life are more random than others.

How does this refute my point? Everything in life is random to some degree or another. Football also is.

> And however skilled they may be, the large number of (fallible) people on the field playing this game certainly doesn't make it less random.

What does fallibility have to do with it? Look, my point is that it is not a roulette wheel, there are humans reacting, and that human endeavour is what's interesting to people, not the precise quantity of randomness in the result.

> As games go, soccer doesn't have many structural impediments to randomness.

It also doesn't have much impediment to strategy, tactics and individual skill drastically altering the probabilities of each individual event.

> We'd (hopefully) feel pretty silly if we got worked up every few years about a global coin-flipping tournament, but, here we are, getting worked up over teams of people engaged in an event where the outcome is dominated by chance.

Clearly football falls somewhere in between a coin-flip tournament and say 9-ball pool. But, again, randomness keeps it interesting. Remember, we are not just looking at results, we are watching players play. In individual situations players make decisions and physically control what happens. You can argue about the randomness of these events, but that just leads towards the tiresome free-will-is-an-illusion debate.

> (And oh, hey: it sort of pegs the irony-o-meter that you're accusing the author of being closed-minded about sports when you can't even be bothered to read an argument because you've decided that you disagree with it in advance. Well played.)

What an uncalled for and arrogant remark that can do nothing except derail reasonable debate; if you squint hard enough everyone is a hypocrite. I did read the argument, and I was addressing the opening presentation.

Re:Is soccer anything more than Poisson noise? by timr on Monday June 23, 2014 @06:51PM (#7935258)
I have no axe to grind. I read the post; you said you didn't read it in the first line of your comment.
Re:Is soccer anything more than Poisson noise? by dasil003 on Tuesday June 24, 2014 @06:55AM (#7937011)
Yes, and I argued against precisely the opening paragraph, I did not argue against the stats legitimacy. It simply does not follow that because there is a great degree of randomness in sports results that sports fandom is based on numerology. Sports fandom is based on the fact that people like playing and watching sports, not reading the result in a paper having never seen the game and making grandiose conclusions about which team is better based on specious reasoning. Everyone knows the better team doesn't always win, it's self evident. What matters are the plays that brought us to that point.

The whole thesis that sports viewing is pointless because it's random is an infuriating straw man. Why not just stick to the thesis that soccer is random and leave the value judgement aside? The exact same thing could be presented without pissing people off with an implicit value judgement of something which the author doesn't care to understand. This sort of innocent condescension is a big reason some youthfully exuberant geeks get picked on in school.

Re:Is soccer anything more than Poisson noise? by cwyers on Monday June 23, 2014 @04:10PM (#7934294)
"His contention is that soccer, more than most other sports, is a poisson machine. He goes into the math."

No he doesn't. He shows that the final score of a soccer game can be modeled by a Poisson distribution. He doesn't look at the distribution of final scores and other sports and compare them.

Re:Is soccer anything more than Poisson noise? by icebraining on Monday June 23, 2014 @03:39PM (#7934092)
If it was robots playing no one would care.

Not true: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RoboCup :)

Re:Is soccer anything more than Poisson noise? by dasil003 on Monday June 23, 2014 @03:42PM (#7934115)
I rest my case.