News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Teaching creationism as scientifically valid now banned i... by DanBC on Monday June 23, 2014 @04:25AM (#7930814)
> If you allow for the possibility of a god, you're not doing science.

No, that's nonsense. It is perfectly possible to do rigorous science but to believe in a God. There is nothing in science that rules out a god.

Sadly the vocal majority of people who believe in a god also believe weird stupid obviously wrong things about science. I'm not talking about those people.

Re:Teaching creationism as scientifically valid now banned i... by thaumasiotes on Monday June 23, 2014 @11:43AM (#7932539)
I think it's worth repeating a point from earlier. Yes, there are many people doing science and avowing belief in a god. However, none of them are involving any god in the science that they do. Their gods are tightly restricted to areas of the universe that they don't practice in. This isn't a coincidence -- as I said in the quote you object to, allowing the possibility of a god means you're not doing science. But there are lots of scientists (really, this is the group of all scientists) who don't practice in every area at once.
Re:Teaching creationism as scientifically valid now banned i... by PPLwynSPFJ5p on Friday June 27, 2014 @06:07PM (#7956502)
I don't think Newton thought of it that way.
Re:Teaching creationism as scientifically valid now banned i... by thaumasiotes on Monday June 23, 2014 @05:41AM (#7931009)
Science proceeds on the assumption that effects can be replicated. Its stated goal is to discover the principles that govern any phenomenon.

If principles govern a phenomenon, god can't. The only god allowed by science is a god with no power to affect anything in the world, or at least no more power to affect the world than a human or any other mundane creature has. The question then is why you want to apply the word "god" to that entity.

http://www.cectic.com/051/