Re:Teaching creationism as scientifically valid now banned i...
by thaumasiotes on Monday June 23, 2014 @11:43AM
(#7932539)
I think it's worth repeating a point from earlier. Yes, there are many people doing science and avowing belief in a god. However, none of them are involving any god in the science that they do. Their gods are tightly restricted to areas of the universe that they don't practice in. This isn't a coincidence -- as I said in the quote you object to, allowing the possibility of a god means you're not doing science. But there are lots of scientists (really, this is the group of all scientists) who don't practice in every area at once.
Re:Teaching creationism as scientifically valid now banned i...
by PPLwynSPFJ5p on Friday June 27, 2014 @06:07PM
(#7956502)
I don't think Newton thought of it that way.
Re:Teaching creationism as scientifically valid now banned i...
by thaumasiotes on Monday June 23, 2014 @05:41AM
(#7931009)
Science proceeds on the assumption that effects can be replicated. Its stated goal is to discover the principles that govern any phenomenon.
If principles govern a phenomenon, god can't. The only god allowed by science is a god with no power to affect anything in the world, or at least no more power to affect the world than a human or any other mundane creature has. The question then is why you want to apply the word "god" to that entity.
No, that's nonsense. It is perfectly possible to do rigorous science but to believe in a God. There is nothing in science that rules out a god.
Sadly the vocal majority of people who believe in a god also believe weird stupid obviously wrong things about science. I'm not talking about those people.