News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why The Cool Kids Don't Use Erlang by decentrality on Sunday June 22, 2014 @11:02AM (#7928001)
What I would like addressed by someone from Erlang is the reality of Celluloid in Ruby, and do honest comparisons.

http://celluloid.io

Otherwise, the speaker seems like a good representative, but the presentation is so verbose it makes me want to concurrently handle his thesis asynchronously in parallel threads and remove the human... in jRuby, using Celluloid.

Re:Why The Cool Kids Don't Use Erlang by lelf on Sunday June 22, 2014 @11:28AM (#7928079)
It's different game. Nothing is shared (think: one gc per thread), can run 10M+ threads on one cpu and effectively schedule all of them (it has one-of-a-kind scheduler counting reductions, you cannot cpu lock even if you want), really transparent distributive programming, state of the art introspection: "login" to remote process on different node, see how many messages in the mailbox of some process, hot (= replace running code) code reloading etc.

Edit: Essentially: some actor library for language X is not even remotely (if any) erlang. Maybe cloud haskell some day will be there, but its all introspection parts is basically nonexistent right now.

Re:Why The Cool Kids Don't Use Erlang by rubiquity on Sunday June 22, 2014 @11:31AM (#7928088)
I'm a long time Rubyist that is new to the Erlang world by way of Elixir mostly. I did use Celluloid in Ruby and it is actually what eventually lead me to Erlang/Elixir.

I think Celluloid is neat and a great set of abstractions for multi threading in Ruby. However, there's more to actors than just having it implemented in a library. Erlang's VM was designed for the actor model whereas Ruby MRI is not. Celluloid actors run in OS threads which can't scale to hundreds of thousands where as Erlang processes can. Using Celluloid with JRuby is closer but still not quite the same.

All that said, Celluloid is damn cool and Tony Arcieri did incredible work on it.

Re:Why The Cool Kids Don't Use Erlang by Allan_Smithee on Monday June 23, 2014 @09:55AM (#7931914)
Everybody thinks that the identifying characteristic of Erlang is the "Actor"(-like) model.

This is untrue.

This is also why all the "Actor"(-like) libraries grafted on to other programming languages that proudly proclaim themselves "Erlang-like" are wrong and make me laugh out loud when I run across them.