News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When Do We Get Robot Cars? Because Driving Really Sucks by dragonwriter on Friday June 20, 2014 @09:03AM (#7920487)
> Still doesn't make much sense to me. A tank, helicopter or fighter jet can all move in 360 degrees, allowing for the full use of a joystick or two.

(1) A car can move in 360 degrees too (if you can rotate a full circle in a plane...)

(2) All it takes to make full use of a joystick is to have controls with two relevant dimensions (which cars have).

(3) A helicopter typically needs a lot more than a joystick, since it usually has about 4-5 relevant dimensions of control (2D cyclic, 1D collective, 1D yaw, 1D throttle, but the last may be managed automatically in normal operation).

> We can't use two joysticks like a tank because it would sheer the rubber from your tires

You could, with the right control regime (e.g., double forward is drive, double back is reverse, but any other combination is based on relative position), but you probably wouldn't want to. Of course, you know what else often doesn't use "two joysticks like a tank" -- actual tanks. Because two joysticks is overkill for two degrees of freedom .

> That and it seems confusing and unsafe to have both direction and throttle controls on one device, especially when that device is as sensitive as a joystick.

"As sensitive as a joystick" isn't meaningful. Degree of sensitivity on a joystick can be as little or as much as you want.

> When you slam on brakes in a car, the force pushes your body further into the breaking system. If you were to slam on the brakes with a joystick, the force would push you (and the joystick) forward, disengaging the brakes and applying throttle.

My first instinct with a joystick based system with a car would be to have brake being forward, not back. (Forward push brakes are a common control element in hand controls for autos, e.g., those that are made for the handicapped.)

There are no comments on this comment yet.