News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why C++ is not my favourite language by dtf on Friday August 28, 2009 @01:44PM (#791851)
C++ hits a certain sweet spot. In some cases - whether you like it or not - it's just the right tool for the job. Two examples I can think of are:

* VM implementations (I mentioned Factor, but also HotSpot, Microsoft's CLR, SquirrelFish, TraceMonkey, V8 and Opera's Carakan are all high-performance VMs written in C++ (x). Note also that all major layout engines are written in C++. Complex but fast and highly-tuned beasts)

* Production rendering. PRMan, MentalRay and pretty much every other renderer in day-to-day use on film and video post-production are written in C++.

People who write these systems care deeply about performance. They'll dip into assembly when they have to. While fast, C won't cut it because in these cases, it doesn't give you enough abstraction to avoid making your code a mess (strong typing, operator overloading and templates in particular, but also virtual method dispatch)*. I'm sure if you ask them, they'd tell you that they'd love to use something nicer and more modern. But it doesn't yet exist.

This is not to say that C++ is the right tool for writing web applications, or even the average desktop application, or even - increasingly these days - games. But somebody needs to write the stack underneath, and that stack needs to be fast.

(x) note Mono as an example of a VM that sticks with C. But it contains a lot of object-oriented shennanigans that probably could be better expressed in C++, and the core developers came from a strong C culture.

Re:Why C++ is not my favourite language by eru on Friday August 28, 2009 @04:39PM (#792240)
How about D? A friend of mine uses it as a better C++ for mathematical programming (optimization, graphs and so on).

Perhaps nobody would have invented C++ if D would have come earlier.

Re:Why C++ is not my favourite language by dtf on Friday August 28, 2009 @05:11PM (#792299)
Yes, D shows a great deal of promise. Maybe I'm short-sighted, but at the moment it's the only language I can see being a viable replacement for what C++ does well. D was invented by Walter Bright, after he had written a C++ compiler (and somehow kept his marbles). I think it was his take on a better C++. Quite a few other clever people have jumped on board to help with the design since.