I had the same experience and hold the same view.
As software developers, We've been taught that a good solution to a problem is a "generic" one, a "one fits all" solution.
for example, in this case, a solution that would fit "all" people interested in "any" topic.
The thing is, for all non-tech problems, the best solution is usually the specific one, the custom made one.
Most of the time when you try a generic solution, competitors specializing in a specific solution would beat you.
Jeff Atwood wrote about a similar idea and called it rule of the 3 [1]. I vaguely remember that he also wrote that they used this rule when starting StackOverflow.
is it still exist? what is it's name/url?
Re:Show HN: Topic
by michaelmior on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @01:22PM
(#7911315)
Not sure what the status is, but posting has been dead for a while. http://www.joinbunch.com/
In the end, things didn't work out out. I think part of the reason is that people only care deeply about a small number of topics and they're willing to go where the community is.