News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Topic by krapp on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @10:59AM (#7910459)
It feels like twitter except with "categories" replacing tags. Nothing necessarily wrong with that I guess, but I don't see why I would necessarily join. Besides there not being an english translation of the terms and conditions yet, I mean.

The random topic effect is nice but how can I find a specific topic, or set of related topics, if I'm looking for them? Not having them show up as an easy to guess API makes it all but impossible.

Re:Show HN: Topic by meritt on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @11:05AM (#7910507)
Twitter hashtags. Categorized tumblr posts. Subreddits.

Yeah.. Not really seeing the value this provides, or even a gap it might fill.

Re:Show HN: Topic by mrwnmonm on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @11:25AM (#7910629)
hi, i'm not the creator, i just was curious about your opinions about the site. having the users posting in a place like a group will produce a different kind of posts from what you find on twitter hashtags. subreddits is close ofcourse, but it has a taste of a bookmarking site more than a social network. the gap it might fill is to got to one place to follow my interests, now you have to go to a lot of places ex: groups/people on social networks/news sites
Re:Show HN: Topic by Springtime on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @12:23PM (#7910954)
When clicking the 'Show me more topics' I expected to be able to see all the topics, but rather it's a random assortment with no way to change a URL to find one. There really needs to be human-readable URLs at least for the categories.

The front page could also use an example topic as part of the scrolling page to best illustrate a use case, as there are a vast number of other established sites and forums dedicated to such discussions. The small thumbnail mockup at the top doesn't highlight this enough I don't feel.

If I were to imagine a use for the site personality it might be for off-shoot conversations around something specific that I could link others to, but that would depend on the ease of sign-up.