News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by peeters on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @10:56AM (#7910439)
How about drawing parallels to a similar situation? A child porn ring manages to stay online via using ever-changing URLs and relying on Google's indexing. Prosecutors of course go after the people maintaining the network. But Google still has a moral and legal obligation to stop indexing the network if feasible.

I'd say at the end of the day it's a matter of degree. In both situations, a content provider has been deemed illegal is leveraging Google to stay afloat. But while in one case Google's obligation seems like a no-brainer due to its heinous nature, the other elicits less passion.

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by opendais on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @11:15AM (#7910561)
Using that logic...

Russia can ban all LBGT sites on Google because it has been deemed illegal.

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by peeters on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @03:31PM (#7912226)
That's not my logic at all. The GP asked what this has to do with Google. I'm saying there are clearly scenarios where Google has a responsibility to limit access to content, even content they don't provide. In my opinion, it is not tenable to say "let the courts go after the child pornographers, but Google shouldn't be asked to block access to their content".

And notably, I'm not even arguing that Google should ever be ordered to block sites worldwide. The GP's argument has NOTHING to do with the worldwide nature, on the contrary, that it is worldwide was only parenthetical in the comment. The same argument would stand even if the decision only affected Canada. It argues against involving Google at all, and that's what I'm debating.