News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by kryptiskt on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:14AM (#7909143)
Sounds like something from here would apply:

"Contempt of Court includes the following behaviours:

- Fails to maintain a respectful attitude, remain silent or refrain from showing approval or disapproval of the proceeding

- Refuses or neglects to obey a subpoena

- Willfully disobeys a process or order of the Court

- Interfere with the orderly administration of justice or to impair the authority or dignity of the Court"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contempt_of_court#Canada

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by tezza on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:23AM (#7909166)
I agree, out and out Contempt of Court.

Further, the Judge themselves is in charge of deciding whether Contempt of Court has occurred.

No possible jury to convince or appeal to, just the judge.

They can have you imprisoned in under a day.

Contempt of Court is very serious.

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by vacri on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:43AM (#7909218)
They can have you imprisoned in under a day.

Only if you're in their jurisdiction. And Google isn't a person to jail. And corporations have a way of making these things not attributable to any one person.

However, it would be better to state the argument given by the law professor in the article: "what happens if a Russian court orders Google to remove gay and lesbian sites from its database". Find something that the judge cares about personally, and you'll find a country that opposes it. Google can also complain that it's being targetted - why not Bing? Yahoo? Any other search providers? Does Wikipedia have a page for the company? What about reseller companies, that resell the competitor - not only are they facilitators, they're witting facilitators? What about sites with user reviews? At what point do we draw the moral line about shooting the messenger?

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by Confusion on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @06:16AM (#7909292)

  And Google isn't a person to jail. 
Which nicely illustrates one of the major problems of having granted corporations 'legal person' status: the punishments for various crimes were originally intended to punish natural persons and have never been sufficiently adapted to punish corporations. What's a proper punishment for flagrant contempt of the court by a corporation?

  And corporations have a way of making these things not 
  attributable to any one person.
That is in fact their raison d'être.
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by davidw on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @08:52AM (#7909749)
> That is in fact their raison d'être.

This looks like an example of @ziobrando's "Bullshit asymmetry principle" in action. You whip out some bullshit (unless I'm really misunderstanding what you are saying) in a one liner with no citations, but to refute it, someone would have to talk about the history of corporations, legal theories around them, compare and contrast with societies that never developed a similar idea (an interesting take on things: http://www.amazon.com/Long-Divergence-Islamic-Held-Middle-eb... ), and so on and so forth. That's a lot more effort than simply spouting some snark.

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by ctdonath on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @10:43AM (#7910363)
Thank you. I have long been trying to pin down the description of, and term for, that principle. http://t.bigboxcar.com/post/87256202522/bullshit-asymmetry-p...

There's still a corollary in need of succinct definition/labeling: in context of a casual discussion, you make a fair point in a one liner with no citation, then someone criticizes it (in effect) for lacking peer-reviewed encyclopedic depth & thoroughness. (Ex.: "this car does 0 to 60MPH in 10 seconds" "uh, NO, you're not taking relativity into account! and you didn't cite any certified testing labs!" and from social context you feel compelled to elaborate on why your comment was sufficient, while the other loudly labels you a liar, ignores your objections, and marches off to disrupt other sane conversations.)

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by Confusion on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @12:24PM (#7910960)
Which is why I'm not going to challenge the accusation of 'bullshit'. I don't think the principle applies here.

It does suggest I need to clarify that I believe that it is both the great strength and the great weakness of corporations.

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by annnnd on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @07:40AM (#7909470)
> the punishments for various crimes were originally intended to punish natural persons and have never been sufficiently adapted to punish corporations

Good point! :)

Jail == cannot conduct business for X years?

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by harty65 on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @09:03AM (#7909798)
Russia mostly uses Yandex anyway :)
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by JohnTHaller on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @08:10AM (#7909612)
Contempt of the law by the judge should be a defense against contempt of court. In an ideal world, that is.
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by danudey on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @09:30AM (#7909924)
The lawyers made a compelling case that the law allows for the actions taken by the course, so the judge followed it. That's how the court system works.
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by danielweber on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @07:57AM (#7909555)
Yes, how could doxxing the judge possibly backfire? /s
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by jrockway on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:21AM (#7909158)
Will the US extradite someone to Canada for contempt of court?
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by jacquesm on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:23AM (#7909165)
They could simply seize the assets of Google Montreal.
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by vacri on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:46AM (#7909225)
I imagine Google going dark in Canada would hurt Canada more than it's worth (playing out the fantasy scenario). I don't just mean search, but at this point there'll be plenty of companies that rely on Google Apps, including gmail.
Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by jacquesm on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:51AM (#7909242)
Yes, but the law will generally not bend so readily to blackmail as people think it will.

Companies like Apple, Google, Facebook and other global IT companies are at an advantage here because they can always pack up and move but if they start pissing off the legal system in the larger economies it may very well backfire.

For 'brick and mortar' companies such tricks are a lot harder to pull off. Also, to protect against mutual damage governments can enter into collectives which have a lot more power against multi-nationals than any single country.

If a judge orders you 'x', you can appeal but in the meantime it is usually wise do 'x', unless you've very carefully weighed the risks and any fall-out and you decide to make a stand.

It's quite possible this is a case worth doing that for.

Re:Canadian court ruling orders Google to block sites worldwide by vacri on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @05:57AM (#7909251)
Oh, for sure. I'm just playing out a fantasy scenario. I imagine in the google offices that making Canada dark in response would have been passed as a joke, but no-one would seriously think it. And even if they did think of it seriously, the legal team would stomp them before they could do anything.