Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video]
by greedo on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @06:40PM
(#7907471)
Laser is line of sight, limiting your range. And nature has a great way of jamming lasers, called clouds. If you were able to get a decently powered laser in a satellite, it wouldn't be able to control too many aircraft unless it looked like a porcupine. And then it would have to deal with anti-satellite defenses that both China and Russia have spent significant sums on.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
> Laser is line of sight, limiting your range.
Yes, with current equipment it limits your range to somewhere beyond the orbit of the moon. Yes, we can now keep a laser and a receiver tracked on each other from 300000km away.
> And nature has a great way of jamming lasers, called clouds.
There are wavelengths that are not hampered much by clouds.
> If you were able to get a decently powered laser in a satellite
We can.
> it wouldn't be able to control too many aircraft unless it looked like a porcupine.
... but this is a problem, you'd basically be limited in total bandwidth by count of satellites. Meaning you either need to launch a lot of them, or reduce bandwidth per drone.
Being able to ping the moon with a laser doesn't help with terrestrial systems. Just as radar has a horizon limit, so do laser systems. So if you put this on a controller version of an AWACS, you have to deal with attenuation from clouds/weather, and I think keeping a lock on a maneuvering UCAS might be a challenge.
I'm not talking about pinging the moon, I'm talking about maintaining a link with a maneuvering spacecraft in moon orbit.
So this spacecraft you're linking to makes radical 8g maneuvers, changes direction at a 30s/ roll rate, and can change altitude at will?
Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video]
by Already__Taken on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @04:44AM
(#7909073)
Unless you happen to have an autonomous reusable spacecraft with significant cross range ability and enough fuel to continuously change orbits.