News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by baddox on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @05:35PM (#7907152)
> The U.S. military is always fighting the last war. In this case, they aren't even fighting the last several wars, but are still locked into Cold War, pre-drone thinking.

Where are you getting that idea? What other countries use drone warfare? As far as I can, it was the CIA that started the whole drone strike campaign, and I'm not aware of other countries that use it consistently.

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by jfoutz on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @06:00PM (#7907298)
The argument goes, if you want to win the next air war, you should use drones. lots of drones. Air to air combat is all missiles, and each of those missiles is half a million dollars.

Now, I'm not aware of an autonomous drone that can shoot down an f-22 with a missile, but it seems like a solvable technical challenge, especially if you're willing to throw a trillion dollars at the problem.

So anyway, for each f-22 send up 7 drones. one for each missile, and one to survive to get the kill, as long as the 6 lost drones are cheaper than the f22, you're winning, kinda.

Furthermore, pilots are expensive and take time to replace. I doubt there are even 10,000 combat pilots in the world (wag) kill off a few thousand, and the drones are against rookies. All the while, the drone software is improving and getting even tougher to kill. And, the drones should be capable of things that that human pilots just can't accomplish - high g turns for example.

Self driving cars aren't better than the best drivers, but they're way above average drivers, eventually the robots will be better. Same with jets. why not start now?

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by greeneggs on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @12:08AM (#7908483)
> What other countries use drone warfare?

This doesn't exactly answer your question, but it is an interesting article along these lines: http://www.economist.com/node/14299496

A few quotes:

"Countries with 'hunter-killer' drones include America, Britain and Israel."

"'Almost all' IDF [Israeli Defense Force] ground operations now have drone support."

"...Estimates that America will spend about 60% of the total [global sales of drones]."

"Following the United States, Israel ranks second in the development and possession of drones, according to those in the industry. The European leaders, trailing Israel, are roughly matched: Britain, France, Germany and Italy. Russia and Spain are not far behind, and nor, say some experts, is China... In total, more than three dozen countries operate UAVs, including Belarus, Colombia, Sri Lanka and Georgia. Some analysts say Georgian armed forces, equipped with Israeli drones, outperformed Russia in aerial intelligence during their brief war in August 2008. (Russia also buys Israeli drones.)"

"Iran builds drones, one of which was shot down over Iraq by American forces in February... Iran has supplied Hizbullah militants in Lebanon with a small fleet of drones, though their usefulness is limited."

Re:Pierre Sprey on the F-35 [video] by wahsd on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:02PM (#7908175)
Other countries aren't warmongers that are constantly looking for the next large scale conflict they can use to rationalize irrational levels of spending.

No other country has had any kind of conflict where a drone would have provided any advantage. Hell, even our drones are not effective and cause more problems than they are worth. We just like being screwed and bamboozled by the next big thing our military services complex has to sell us.

If you have any idea of the consequences and effects of using drones in tactical operations then you would know that if any other country was using them in the way we use them we would be crying foul and trying to passive aggressively shame them for killing innocent civilians.