News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Literally worse than EA by throwaway_yy2Di on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @06:22AM (#7903575)

    "The EULA for Minecraft says you can’t make money of
    Minecraft. If you make mods, they have to be free."
I don't understand the legal theory behind this. Is this contract law? If a programmer wrote a third-party mod without buying the software (say by reading an API description), would they still be bound to its terms?

Also, does restricting modification like this infringe on "first sale" rights?

Re:Literally worse than EA by belorn on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:27AM (#7904593)
A court held that when a defendant purchased old copies of National Geographic magazine, tore out articles, and bound them together for sale with articles relating to a common subject matter, it had infringed on the owner’s exclusive right to prepare derivative works. Nat’l Geographic Soc’y v. Classified Geographic, Inc., 27 F. Supp. 655 (D. Mass. 1939).

Even if you do not do any copying, you can still infringe under copyright law. The theory is that the copyright owner has exclusively power to decide who should compile, adapt or arrange a copyrighted work.

I recommend further reading at: http://digitalcommons.law.wne.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?articl...

Re:Literally worse than EA by drdeca on Wednesday June 18, 2014 @04:14AM (#7909004)
I would have thought that right of first sale should guarantee the right to do that. I guess not?
Re:Literally worse than EA by tokenizerrr on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:19AM (#7903730)
Minecraft does not have an API currently. If you are making mods you are decompiling the original Minecraft java source code, modifying it, and releasing a modified version of their original works.
Re:Literally worse than EA by indiv0 on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:24AM (#7904243)
Actually their EULA states that you are not allowed to redistribute Mojang's code (compiled or decompiled) in any way.

Mods are created using the decompiled client, and built against that. But when they are released, they do not contain any of Mojang's code.

Installing mods is done by copying compiled .class files into the client .jar

Re:Literally worse than EA by Filligree on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @01:49PM (#7905822)
> Installing mods is done by copying compiled .class files into the client .jar

This is no longer true, except for Forge. What you're talking about is the old-style mod system, which has been obsolete for some number of years; nowadays they're dynamically linked from iterating over the mods/ folder.

Re:Literally worse than EA by bradleyjg on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @10:38AM (#7904664)
Blizzard has won some cases like this. Here's one complaint: https://pdf.yt/d/exHXLZNbCvuVq3v0

The causes of action are: direct and secondary infringement of registered copyrights, trafficking in circumvention devices, breach of contract, and intentional interference with contractual relations.

A couple of those might not apply in a clean room implementation, but the others would.

Re:Literally worse than EA by drewcrawford on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:08AM (#7903695)
Well I'm no lawyer, but one legal theory you could argue is the one from MAI vs Peak. This is the one that holds that loading a computer program into ram for running is a copy that requires permission from the copyright holder. Therefore one would argue that by running this program, they ratified the EULA, or else they blatantly committed copyright infringement, which is probably worse than simple breach of contract.

I know there are lawyers who seem to argue otherwise, for example the GPL states "You are not required to accept this license to receive or run a copy of the program". But I don't know if that statement has any legal basis in general, or if it's just the FSF granting permission to run covered software without accepting the GPL. As far as the US goes, I think it's the latter, but it may be different in other jurisdictions.

I'm not a lawyer, please go hire someone if you really need to know.

Re:Literally worse than EA by tptacek on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @06:31AM (#7903604)
You're asking if there's such a thing as an enforceable noncommercial license?
Re:Literally worse than EA by throwaway_yy2Di on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @06:36AM (#7903613)
Well there are well-known noncommercial clauses about redistribution of software. But this license is about restricting third-party modifications, like plugins, which don't contain copyrighted code, but do link to it and target its API. So yes I'm asking if that's enforceable, and what type of law allows for that (contract or copyright?).

Or did you mean noncommercial use, as in evaluation licenses?

(edit: several edits because I am confused)

Re:Literally worse than EA by avz on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:28AM (#7903756)
I think the recent Oracle vs Google case is relevant here as it involves the question of whether APIs are copyrightable. The case is about a subset of Java APIs included in Android. Note that the Android implementation exposed by those APIs is new and did not involve copying code from Java standard libraries (modulo rangeCheck()).

The district court ruled that so long as implementation is different you are free to provide the same API. A federal circuit court reversed this ruling this year. The case is now back in the district court for consideration of whether the use of the API falls under the fair-use clause.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oracle_v._Google

Re:Literally worse than EA by throwaway_yy2Di on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:48AM (#7903824)
One difference is that mods are meant to be linked against the proprietary implementation. In the discussion of GPL linking, this is really murky:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU_General_Public_License#Lin...

But I don't think either of those are really similar. Android is emulating the Java API, without Oracle code being involved. Programs that link against GPL libraries are intended to make runtime calls to copyrighted code. And game mods modify the copyrighted program's runtime behavior, having the program make calls to the modding code (in place of its own). I can't think of an analogue of the last situation.

Re:Literally worse than EA by nl on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @07:52AM (#7903843)
Minecraft doesn't have an official API, so modding involves decompiling and shipping recompiled Mojang-owned code. I'm pretty sure a restriction on that would hold up in most jurisdictions.