You don't see disruption everywhere, for example Google and Facebook are hardly 'disruptive' as companies, but I think in the right cases the theory has predictive power and is a necessary tool in the belt of people who work in technology.
1. http://www.nytimes.com/2014/03/25/business/media/disney-buys...
However, I'm not sure how you see Google as not disruptive...? By revenue, it's an advertising company, and a different ballgame from print media etc. (advertisers get live feedback on performance - focus groups can't match that). The bidding idea is also brillant (from goto/overture) - google gets the highest possible price, but your competitor is the bad guy. Though I guess you might say it's the internet that's disruptive, and google's just along for the ride.
But it seems pretty unclear if the theory of disruptive innovation has any predictive power at all.
You seem to be avoiding coming down on one side or the other. Do you think the theory has predictive power? If so, on what basis do you think that?