Re:Hamlet – Simple and powerful reactive templating
by chenglou on Monday June 16, 2014 @07:45PM
(#7902116)
Comparing your CoffeeScript example against a vanilla JS React example seems cheap. here's the front page React example in CS:
Showing a LOC comparison (and not even from the same dialect of a language) isn't a good proof for what you're trying to demonstrate. Clarity, simplicity, and debuggability all count. Removing a few extra lines of (non-boilerplate) code compared to React doesn't make the library simpler to work with.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Hamlet – Simple and powerful reactive templating
by mdiebolt on Monday June 16, 2014 @08:05PM
(#7902181)
I thought about that when constructing the demo but opted to use the JSX / plain JavaScript version because that's what's displayed on the React homepage.
We have a strong preference for Haml and CoffeeScript dialects so that's how we present our demos. I built jsfiddles based on how each framework presented their own product.
Re:Hamlet – Simple and powerful reactive templating
by chenglou on Monday June 16, 2014 @08:33PM
(#7902259)
It is indeed displayed on the front page, in vanilla JS, but that doesn't change the fact that it's not a very accurate comparison, providing that the point you're trying to prove is LOC. The React version also showcased attributes such as `className`, which Hamlet didn't. Nothing against CoffeeScript; just picking on the comparison itself.
Also, React is a view library, not a full-stack framework. The fact that it's put on the same level as other real JS frameworks is an acknowledgment of its paradigm's power and usefulness. So I guess people viewing it as a framework is a misleading but very telling phenomenon.
That being said, good luck with the project!