i've never been able to remember who someone is or what they do. the benefit of trusting A more on a security issue because A has proven himself to be a master of security issues...well, that's a tough problem. i'd rather see anonymous names, no karma and a security certificate.
karma is useful to draw n00bs into the system--i found it pretty darn cool when i started out. now i don't care at all. after 200 points they should disappear: now you've earned yourself a real soul.
So -1 anything that would obscure my name more than a handle with a link to my profile does.
If all domain names were removed from the blogosphere it would enable a more fair distribution of readership, but it wouldn't make for a better reading experience. It would also mean the regulars would have to qualify things more often.
Basically I care more about utility than fairness and I think reputation is a concept with significant utility.
http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=190451
( my memory is a gift and a curse ;) )
PG's my hero, but how would you escape the negative sign below for a Google search so it works:
"-9 points by pg" site:news.ycombinator.com
I haven't had much success.
From your comment : Perhaps it just shows how no one really gets it, and why bother explaining if you do: those who know don't tell.
IMHO this is a dangerous attitude to have towards a disagreement, as it can cloud your thinking.
"You're forgetting something", you may get:
"tdavis, you're forgetting something."