News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kingston and PNY using cheaper components after good reviews by mikeash on Sunday June 15, 2014 @12:11AM (#7894344)
It seems to me that focusing on component changes is completely missing the point. The real problem was not that Apple had two subtly different versions of their MacBook Pro with no way to tell them apart. The real problem was that Apple was shipping seriously defective hardware. Imagine if Apple hand standardized entirely on the defective LG panels. That eliminates the "panel lottery" complaint, right? And yet the actual problem, in terms of what you get when you buy one, is worse, not better.

Manufacturers need to ship products that are fit for purpose and that perform as advertised. As long as that's maintained, swapping components shouldn't be a problem. If swapping components affects that, then it's the bad products, not the swapping, that are the real problem.

Re:Kingston and PNY using cheaper components after good reviews by sigterm on Sunday June 15, 2014 @03:13AM (#7894648)
I totally agree with you. For this particular article, if there is a clear and comprehensive specification on how the drives should perform (IOPs, latency, BW, etc), the problem will be resolved immediately with no controversy. The comment I was replying to implied that Apple should provide a means for customers to distinguish the products, which I do not believe is a realistic solution because swapping components is quite common in hardware world.
Re:Kingston and PNY using cheaper components after good reviews by mikeash on Sunday June 15, 2014 @10:35AM (#7895300)
I agree with you too! I'm just expanding on that a bit, and saying how even if distinguishing the products was somehow realistic, it's solving the wrong problem anyway.