News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by latch on Saturday June 14, 2014 @11:06PM (#7894241)
I wasn't thinking about caffeine (but if that's the issue, tea or coffee seem like good alternative). I was thinking about the health issues its linked to (kidney problems, type 2 diabetes, dental issues, ...)
Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by gavinpc on Saturday June 14, 2014 @11:15PM (#7894255)
It's the aspartame.

You can decide for yourself whether it's poison, but it's definitely the reason many people regard diet sodas as such.

EDIT, I guess this should have gone on parent. At any rate, latch, I had the exact same reaction. And this is a man with resources. (Indeed, maybe he drinks some secret power soda and just used Diet Coke to give it a plebian air. Maybe such details are even handled by his blogging software.)

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by mikeash on Saturday June 14, 2014 @11:23PM (#7894268)
Aren't those health problems avoided when drinking diet? Not that it's necessarily super healthy, but I thought sugar was the great enemy here.
Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by josai on Sunday June 15, 2014 @02:22AM (#7894579)
I'm not so sure. I'm certainly not an expert, but I have a private theory that the very sweetness of artificial sweeteners influences insulin release via some mechanism. Whether by "crying wolf" and promoting insulin resistance, or by some other means, I suspect there's some kind of message at play - "lots of sugar coming, blood, get ready!" - which then has a deleterious effect even when there's no actual sugar involved.

Well, it's not very scientific, but I've arrived at this theory by a couple of observations. One in myself - I used to be a huge diet coke junkie, up to 10 cans a day sometimes, and I found it impossible to lose weight, plus I noticed that I got that "after sugar" feeling somehow from the drink. When I cut it out, plus everything else artificially sweet (I was barely consuming any sugar), my weight loss issues disappeared and I just felt .. much better.

The other side of my anecdotal data comes from observing the same thing in friends. I know a few people who have gone pretty heavily low carb to lose weight, and I note a seeming correlation between success and cutting out sweet foods/drinks, no matter if they have sugar or not. OK, it's not exactly a double blind large-scale test, but nonetheless.

I'm not the only one I know who thinks this either. A couple of the PTs at my gym have noticed the same thing, and advise their clients to cut everything sweet from their diet, fake sugar or not. And Tim Ferriss advises a maximum of one diet drink a day.

So yeah, if you ask me (or the people above) - stay away from diet soft drinks and anything else sweet. I can't point to any large-scale studies, but over the years I've become pretty convinced there's something there.

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by 1stop on Sunday June 15, 2014 @06:20AM (#7894936)
The reason you can't point to any large scale studies is because all of them found aspartame to be harmless, not induce an insulin response, etc (i.e the complete opposite of your theory).

Diet coke hates are in the same category as anti-vacs campaigners... They don't believe in science.

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by fiblye on Sunday June 15, 2014 @07:08AM (#7894987)
I came across something contrary to that.

"Data from large, epidemiologic studies support the existence of an association between artificially-sweetened beverage consumption and weight gain in children."

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2951976/

One thing to keep in mind is that studies of diet and nutrition are always very hazy and go back and forth constantly. Human lifespans are long and diets are complex, so it's difficult to say whether or not any one thing is "harmless." Saturated fats were thought to be a major cause of heart disease for a long time, but now that's apparently no longer true.

http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230367840...

I don't think comparing anti-diet soda drinkers and antivaxers is really a fair comparison. Soda and artificial sweeteners aren't in any way beneficial for anybody; vaccines save countless lives.

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by 1stop on Sunday June 15, 2014 @09:53AM (#7895229)
Well, if artificial sweeteners caused a reduced (or zero) insulin response (which science says they do), and thus lowered the risk of obesity, then a (tenuous, though real) causal link can be made between saving lives, and artificial sweeteners, no?
Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by josai on Sunday June 15, 2014 @11:07AM (#7895378)
The parent linked to a study demonstrating a link between aspartame and obesity. Did you even look at it before you wrote your facetious little reply? If you do, you'll notice it says the opposite of what you seem to think it does.

And stop invoking the word "science" like it's an infallible deity whispering in your (and only your) ear. Science is a process and IMO the result is not in on this one yet.

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by 1stop on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @09:07AM (#7904152)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aspartame_controversy

Okay, I get it, you are upset that I implied you were an anti-vaccer.

I'm sorry for being facetious too: No smiling, serious business here.

> Science is a process and IMO the result is not in on this one yet.

On aspartame it's well and truly in. That's my point. If I haven't provided enough references, just google[0] it and read ALL the science. It's been studied to death and back again.

I hate to say it, but now you're the one being a dick. :(

[0] scholar.google.com

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by cornholio on Sunday June 15, 2014 @12:04PM (#7895519)
It's not a link (causation), it's an association (correlation). Which should be more than obvious, fat people drink diet coke precisely because they are fat, it makes no sense to prefer that wretched taste if you are not weight-conscious.
Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by saalweachter on Sunday June 15, 2014 @01:30PM (#7895745)
There is a lot of variation in how people taste artificial sweeteners.

In my informal surveys, some people think Diet Coke tastes sweeter than regular Coke, and some people think regular Coke tastes sweeter. In general, people seem to prefer the one that tastes less sweet.

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by josai on Sunday June 15, 2014 @06:57AM (#7894983)
That was a needlessly hostile and insulting response. I'm merely pointing out some personal experiences, and made appropriate qualifications to that effect.

And your blanket dismissal is doubtful anyway. Here's a study clearly indicating correlation between aspartame and insulin response: http://care.diabetesjournals.org/content/30/7/e59.full Cephalic-phase insulin release is a known phenomenon and could obviously be triggered by expectation of a diet drink.

Being skeptical of mainstream nutritional "science" (barely worthy of the name, IMO, and which has led to an unprecedented obesity epidemic) is in no way comparable to "anti-vaxxers". And frankly, if I noticed a very strong correlation between people I knew who'd been vaccinated and then all suddenly became autistic, I'd be asking questions too, and would be right to do so, and that spirit of skeptical enquiry is the very essence of science.

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by 1stop on Sunday June 15, 2014 @09:59AM (#7895238)
Sorry, I didn't mean to be that hostile, and I seem to have continued that in my other responses. Apoligises to all.

There is a lot of mis-information around artificial sweeteners, I think it just triggers my "Frustrated with the internet" nerve or something.

I agree, be skeptical, question, don't take things at face value. But, I'd add: be informed, look up where we are at in current day research. Diabetic research is huge, it isn't generally something to be skeptical of, there are people who's lives are saved, preserved, made better because of that research.

But again, sorry for being a dick. :)

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by josai on Sunday June 15, 2014 @11:13AM (#7895393)
Well, apology accepted I suppose. However..

> There is a lot of mis-information around artificial sweeteners

Sure is. And perhaps you're contributing to it. You sure haven't produced any evidence that you're right and everyone else is wrong.

> it just triggers my "Frustrated with the internet"

Well, your belligerent responses to people's polite, reasonable comments kind of trigger that in me. Let's not be part of the problem...

> look up where we are at in current day research

There have been two studies linked to supporting the claims made by myself and others. You haven't posted anything. Take your own advice!

> Diabetic research is huge, it isn't generally something to be skeptical of

And yet we're living in an unprecedented, worldwide obesity epidemic. Someone is obviously very wrong about something. It's my personal belief that in 50 years we'll be looking back on current nutritional "science" the same way we look back on "healthy cigarettes" in the 60s. We'll get it right eventually, but we sure haven't yet.

(edited for politeness)

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by 1stop on Tuesday June 17, 2014 @08:43AM (#7904030)
Hmm, two studies.

Try this:

http://scholar.google.com.au/scholar?q=diabetes+and+diet&btn...

The rest of your post seems to be just rhetoric vaguely around your injured pride and the subsequent posturing.

Again I am sorry I upset you.

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by hollerith on Sunday June 15, 2014 @09:10AM (#7895154)
If a person is able to make good decisions even when as is the case here the peer-reviewed science points strongly in neither direction, he will be able to win more often at life than someone that must rely on peer-reviewed science.

I avoid all artificial sweeteners (and Stevia) for essentially the same reasons as grandparent BTW.

But even if one pays attention only to peer-reviewed studies, one will make bad decisions if one misinterprets them. Your dismissal of the author of grandparent as someone who doesn't "believe in science" suggests to me that you do not know how correctly to interpret the peer-reviewed studies here (which again I believe do not point strongly in either direction). (For most questions people have about diet and health, the peer-reviewed studies, when interpreted correctly, do not point strongly in any one direction.)

In particular, studies showing that aspartame does not induce an insulin response are not particularly strong evidence against grandparent's assertion that with all of the artificial sweeteners, <<there's some kind of message at play - "lots of sugar coming, blood, get ready!">> For something as central to the metabolism of living things as the common dietary sugars, there will be hundreds of molecules besides insulin involved.

It would take many many paragraphs to explain the case against artificial sweeteners in enough detail for there to be any hope of your following the explanation. I do not want to write those paragraphs. I'm just briefly adding my support to what I consider an illuminating and well-written comment (grandparent).

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by 1stop on Sunday June 15, 2014 @09:44AM (#7895211)
> For something as central to the metabolism of living things as the common dietary sugars, there will be hundreds of molecules besides insulin involved.

See, you sound exactly like an anti-vacser... Insulin is the "Lots of sugar coming, blood, get ready" response. There isn't hundreds of other molecules involved... there is insulin. Do you see type I diabetics injecting anything else into themselves?

Please, take many paragraphs and explain, because your vague bullshit ridden comment, is far from convincing.

Re:Have You Hugged a Concrete Pillar Today? by sliverstorm on Saturday June 14, 2014 @11:37PM (#7894290)
I really need to do some digging, see if there are any relevant studies... see, I don't think I have met anyone with any particular issues, who drinks soda in moderation.

Remember, the dose makes the poison.