News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Porn collection put people off upgrading to Firefox 3 by michael_dorfman on Thursday August 27, 2009 @03:43AM (#788843)
There's a nice object lesson here about fully understanding the impact of a system change on your users. Making things "better" for them often isn't.
Re:Porn collection put people off upgrading to Firefox 3 by kingsley_20 on Thursday August 27, 2009 @03:49AM (#788848)
Actually, I think that the lesson is more of balancing existing, niche user needs against prospective mass user needs. Almost nobody gets this right, but it's a wonderfully challenging game.

For one, I would have made the awesome-bar return some search results as well, and made it impossible to distinguish between those and the bookmark results. They could also have compared auto-completes against whitelists/blacklists.

Re:Porn collection put people off upgrading to Firefox 3 by FooBarWidget on Thursday August 27, 2009 @03:52AM (#788851)
With that kind of attitude, user interfaces should never, ever change. I don't think a conservative attitude like this is the path to success.
Re:Porn collection put people off upgrading to Firefox 3 by philh on Thursday August 27, 2009 @05:26AM (#788923)
With that kind of attitude, user interface changes get carefully considered and tested before being rolled out.
Re:Porn collection put people off upgrading to Firefox 3 by FooBarWidget on Thursday August 27, 2009 @08:23AM (#789071)
That's like saying that before writing a blog post, one should consult a psychologist to research every word's implications on human readers.

If you have a multi-billion dollar budget to test every pixel of the user interface then fine, but what if you're an indie developer and have to do with a budget of $100?

Re:Porn collection put people off upgrading to Firefox 3 by Retric on Thursday August 27, 2009 @08:54AM (#789104)
Then do A / B testing.

The "cheep" way to do A / B testing is for B to always be the existing system. Roll out changes to 10% of your users and see how they respond. Just remember if your users hate it then fix the problem and test it again or abandon the idea. So, this only works when you can measure how they resound to changes.

Re:Porn collection put people off upgrading to Firefox 3 by pbhjpbhj on Thursday August 27, 2009 @10:18AM (#789221)
Allow for the change to bed in. When the awesome bar came out I immediately disliked it, possibly hated it even: now I find it both useful and generally awesome. It [the awesome bar] takes time to learn the best response to each key string, now i rarely need to type more than 3 letters to find the address i want, often just one letter.

Also a UI change can get more plaudits by virtue of the placebo effect, IMO (I've not done double blind tests!), making things appear better simply cause the look has changed.

Re:Porn collection put people off upgrading to Firefox 3 by nailer on Thursday August 27, 2009 @01:22PM (#789592)
With that kind of attitude, people will never understand each others differing viewpoints in a respectful way. :^)