Re:Am I an academic?
by neilc on Thursday August 27, 2009 @02:29AM
(#788778)
Work there is published if and only if it is in Microsoft's interest to do so.
Do you have any evidence for that claim?
Often a bare outline is published: enough to impress people but not enough for an outsider to duplicate the work. This isn't academia.
Actually, there are plenty of research papers that describe a system in some detail, but not nearly enough detail to allow an "outsider to duplicate the work". Both academics and industrial researchers sometimes accompany a research paper with a working prototype; in both cases, they often do not.
Do you have any evidence for that claim?
Often a bare outline is published: enough to impress people but not enough for an outsider to duplicate the work. This isn't academia.
Actually, there are plenty of research papers that describe a system in some detail, but not nearly enough detail to allow an "outsider to duplicate the work". Both academics and industrial researchers sometimes accompany a research paper with a working prototype; in both cases, they often do not.