If anything, the evolution of humans as bipedal creatures should have made the legs into the weapons of choice, since they are not only stronger and larger but can be wielded with momentum for increased force. But the legs make for poor weapons because all the vulnerable targets are up high. While the most direct way to hurt someone is actually a straight movement towards someone, our limbs are designed to swing and swivel, not shoot out forward.
If hands were for punching, then the tissues attaching our arms to our bodies would have been designed to issue strikes faster and more powerfully. Currently it's very difficult for humans to issue incredibly rapid strikes with power; we have to use our lats, core, legs, and hips to rotate our bodies to increase momentum in a punch and line up the shoulder with the target, lest you deliver with reduced power. In contrast, kicks can be issued just as fast and with greater power, so one would think that naturally humans would have gravitated to kicking each other rather than punching, but the opposite seems to be the case.
IMHO, the most ideal strike a human can give without injuring themselves would be from the shin or heel. If you look at animals that don't have sharp teeth or claws, often they'll use their hind legs in a kicking motion to provide the most powerful hit, while moving their sensitive head/neck/chest away from the target. A few human groups developed fighting styles this way, but for millenia we've still been fighting standing up. I can only assume this is because we got so used to being bipedal that we adapted our fighting to it. I think our evolution probably prompted us to develop new ways of fighting that were comfortable to our bodies, rather than vice versa.
Most fights between people end up on the ground very quickly. Optimizing for full-stroke punches and kicks effectively forces your strategy to be "debilitate the other guy before he can get inside and close". The difference between humans and the non-toothed/clawed animals you mention is that humans have arms and hands that can defend against the slower knockout blows you mention.
Wrestling is a more accurate sports approximation for how humans "naturally" fight (assuming 1-on-1).
But in serious group fights, willingness to go to the ground fast is willingness to get killed by someone else's feet.
And as soon as you assume a level of technology that includes pointy sticks, retaining mobility becomes VERY important.
Two groups of guys who have some need to fight over are more likely to use tools.
One of the reasons for the excellent track record of safety in Mixed Martial Arts is the lack of reliance on heavy padded gloves.
A traditional boxing glove spreads the impact across a wider area resulting in greater likelihood of brain swelling and life-threatening injury.
Lighter gloves or bare knuckle impacts result in less internal swelling but greater likelihood of skin tears, cuts or out right deflected strikes.
Other myths you have posted -
If anything, the evolution of humans as bipedal creatures should have made the legs into the weapons of choice
Nope. Bipedal animals, particularly humans, are not evolved for effective lower leg striking. It takes years of training to be able to throw a kick which balances effectiveness, accuracy and power versus the risk of leaving oneself vulnerable.
You throw a kick and I will try and gouge your eyes out with my thumbs by grappling you. Let's see who has evolved the greater defence.
While the most direct way to hurt someone is actually a straight movement towards someone
Again, most martial artists and boxers will agree that an effective straight line jab is far less powerful than a hook or uppercut thrown with precision to the lower chin, lower jaw or temple. Very few knockouts ever arise from a straight line punch.
Even gated martials arts such as Wing Chun advocate coming in at an oblique angle whereever possible.
IMHO, the most ideal strike a human can give without injuring themselves would be from the shin or heel
In close quarters the most effective strike you can deliver to a standing human opponent is a knee strike or elbow strike. It takes repeated shin strikes in Muay Thai to weaken or disable the upper thighs or ribs.
All the rest of your descriptions of fighting are based on the evolution of martial arts or a skilled practitioner. What i'm talking about is people who have zero formal training, save for perhaps getting in lots of fights. You seem to overlook the rest of what I wrote, where I describe how people are not built for straight-line strikes, how animals might kick with their hind legs but we don't find that to be natural, how kicks are more difficult to use against higher vulnerable targets, etc. We're basically agreeing, but with different words :)
I don't know why anyone goes for the ribs with a roundhouse if it can just be checked with shins or forearms (and takes more energy for the kicker). If you just make repeated blows to the IT band, even if they can stand the pain, very soon they won't be able to stand on that leg. Same for hooks to the radial so they can't lift their guard or keep their wrist straight. Close fighting is also a bit silly in terms of natural/practical fights; if you're close enough to connect with an elbow, you might as well go for the eyes or throat or work around to a rear naked choke, or something.
You know your fighting. :-)
Perhaps that's true, but isn't it also true that fisticuffs were a "natural" way for impromptu humans fights? I highly doubt that boxing was the first invention of fighting by standing up and punching the other person. It seems more likely that human already tended to fight that way when genuinely angry at each other, and as people began to be interested in fighting prowess, the protective rules of boxing were developed to allow experts to fight for longer.
And, like in any discussion regarding evolution, it's important to point out that phrases like "if hands were for punching" are dangerously close to being deceptive because of the implied attribution of purpose to the evolutionary process.
Or just hitting him over the head with a rock while he slept.
Forager societies more closely resemble middle school than modern life. In modern life, you can get in a fight at the bar and not see the person you lost to for weeks - if ever. In middle school, you lose a fight and you have to see that person every day for the rest of your life - unless you skip town (leave the tribe) - which appears to have been somewhat common.
Thus any fisticuffs victory will be hollow, as the loser can simply murder you one day when you least expect it.
I'm not one for hypothesizing based on hunches that look evolutionarily plausible, but, given that for a long time humans lived to 20, 25 years old, consider the types of fights teenagers and kids get into these days. A few punches, somebody (or both people) loses with some bruises, nobody dies, nobody gets seriously hurt.
We're comparing those types of fights with murders here. Apples to oranges.
Those differences should have similarities to the ones that are claimed to have naturally occurred in prehistoric man.
No amount of skull reinforcement will stand up to a solid strike from a club. And even if it did, it wouldn't matter - our huge brains concuss easily, meaning that even if the bone structure itself remained intact following a club blow, the brain it protects would be quite damaged.
Human weapon use has been discussed as one reason why humans are less sexually dominant than many other primate relatives. Beta chimps don't have the ability to easily murder the reigning alpha chimp in his sleep. Humans do.