Re:Uber sign-ups soar by 850 percent as cab drivers protest
by seanmcdirmid on Thursday June 12, 2014 @11:51AM
(#7884094)
Medallions are meant to regulate supply with demand, nothing more. Other fees go to road maintenance (gas tax, tab tax, tolls, etc...) and are actually sort of related to usage.
Uber is doing what it can disrupt the status quo, the laws are ambiguous enough that they can get away with it. Admirable in my opinion.
Re:Uber sign-ups soar by 850 percent as cab drivers protest
by toomuchtodo on Thursday June 12, 2014 @01:37PM
(#7884827)
Medallions shouldn't be assets you can own, transfer, rentseek on. They should be a lottery, with no cash value if their purpose is to restrict the number of vehicles in a geographic area.
A regressive policy has nothing to do with the goal of the medallions. They cost what market forces will support. The goal of high-end watches is to keep poor people from knowing what time it is.
The medallions aren't for infrastructure. I'd argue the medallions are supported by both the city and existing cabbies because of congestion and quality management issues. It's a way to ensure minimal levels of service and to punish bad (well, abhorrent) service.
The tax on fares is for infrastructure and administration. In NYC, $.50/trip is imposed. What's Uber paying?
I guess Uber couldn't know when it was dealing with a NYC fare subject to the tax... Oh, wait they couldn't offer that since it would imply they were a taxi service subject to other regs... So, they have to flaunt all the laws and put themselves in a legal bind that isn't all "just obvious barriers to entry."