1. Uber drivers don't make as much as Uber PR claims (based on data Uber provided).
2. Uber the business doesn't seem to be wildly profitable, or at least not in a defendable way (based partly on data Uber provided).
3. The large amount of capital being injected into Uber are not indicators of growing real value, but instead indicators of a weaker-than-acknowledged business.
It's possible for all of the above to be true but for drivers and riders to both be very happy with the service. Especially since UberX seems to be offering rides for below market prices but the drivers are getting switching bonuses and per-hour guarantees (see elsewhere in this thread).
Also, who is the boss/supervisor who would fire or penalise the driver for saying it's not great? More importantly, since there no strenuous and expensive licencing going on, it's simple to just stop being an Uber driver if it doesn't suit you.
From the view of the driver it could be you: It's not that uncommon for corporations to test employees like that using HR people disguised as customers. I have no idea whether Uber does that, though.
2. Uber is extremely profitable and growing a ton. The only argument here is about whether its profitability or growth is not sustainable because drivers are getting a bum deal, or merely a run-of-the-mill deal, while all appearances are to the contrary. It's pretty easy to tell when people are happy. Groupon was generally hated by small businesses, while Uber is loved by operators of limos and taxis. People aren't idiots; they know when a service is good for their bottom line and when it isn't.
3. Raising a big round doesn't in itself mean a company is a strong or weak business, though it will increase debate about it.
This is a common way for investors to get screwed, but in this case it may reflect their belief that Uber is well-placed to capitalize on the impending self-driving-car phenomenon. They could be wrong about that, of course, for any number of reasons, but at least it's not Groupon.
FWIW, I've also talked with a handful of uber drivers in SF and LA, and they have all said they are making more money now than they did driving cabs. The biggest difference was indeed utilization - the example given a couple of times was that as taxi drivers, they would drive someone to the airport and have to drive home empty, since they didn't have the necessary licenses to work inside the airport and it wasn't cost effective to hang around hoping for fares on city steets outside their own territory. On the other hand, with Uber they often would drop someone off at the airport and immediately pick up another fare back to their own area.
Long term if cities allow services like Uber and Lyft to exist the margins will likely decrease since drivers can switch to the company that pays the best, and consumers will use the service with the best rates.
The calculations in the article seem to be based on just a couple numbers -- such as the 40,000 miles per year that Uber gave for the purpose of cost of ownership calculation, which is used to try to calculate the hours drivers work and the fare they earn per hour. Some real numbers about fares earned would help here. The conclusion is not clearly stated in the "Conclusion" section, but here's my interpretation: If you make certain assumptions about an uberX driver, you find they make about as much as a typical taxi driver. This suggests that driving uberX instead of a taxi does not automatically put you in a completely different income bracket, but I think the devil is in the details. Obviously the spread between different drivers is much, much larger than the spread between taxis and uberXs. If we made a histogram of income for each and superimposed them, they would be two humps with a lot of overlap. It would be more interesting to know, for example, how the jobs of top-earning uberX drivers and top taxi drivers compare.
Then there are implications that Uber is another Groupon, and its financial success is dependent on a steady stream of investment dollars. Well, Uber is making plenty of money. They write software and do operations and the money just pours in. Every user is a paying customer, and the vast majority of users come away satisfied and happy to have a better way to get from point A to point B. The drivers make money and are thrilled. Some people take Uber literally every day. Seems like a pretty good business to me.