Re:Show HN: PixelBlock – A Gmail extension that blocks email...
by thrownaway2424 on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @03:47PM
(#7880043)
I really really really want a better security model for chrome extensions. As an example, I'd be happy to install this extension if it didn't "have access to" my gmail content, but was somehow able to add DOM matching and mutating callbacks that were run under Gmail. The matching part would be under my control and couldn't be updated by the extension. For example I'd be happy to let this extension mutate any img tag. I'm sure you can find a million holes in this idea, but it would be better than what we have today.
Re:Show HN: PixelBlock – A Gmail extension that blocks email...
by alooPotato on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:18PM
(#7880195)
Maybe if the permission was something like "Let this extension read and mutate stuff on the page but don't let it make any ajax requests". Would that be sufficient?
Re:Show HN: PixelBlock – A Gmail extension that blocks email...
by joshuacc on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:33PM
(#7880272)
Not the person you were responding to, but this could be easily worked around by sticking `img` tags into the page with urls that are crafted to share information.
Re:Show HN: PixelBlock – A Gmail extension that blocks email...
by joev_ on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @04:37PM
(#7880289)
It's still a much, much safer model than Firefox's Add-ons.
Re:Show HN: PixelBlock – A Gmail extension that blocks email...
by ramoq on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @08:59PM
(#7881293)
Perhaps if I threw this on github people could see the code themselves, or better yet; run the extension in dev mode so they can 100% be sure they know the code running.
Appreciate the concerns claudiusd. Just trying to protect people's email privacy :)
Are you installing this at work? What kind of trade secrets could you potentially leak? And how does it affect your corporate compliance requirements? If your email is subject to HIPAA regulation, then you may be leaking protected health information. That's pretty bad.
I, for one, rarely install plugins. I've written plugins for my own amusement that can do some very bad things, and it's just too easy. Think twice people.