Re:Intel Bringing SIMD to JavaScript
by sanxiyn on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @11:27AM
(#7878487)
Won't we have HSA in the future? HSA is supposed to provide unified coherent memory access to both CPU and GPU. Do you think HSA is a pipe dream? If so why?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Intel Bringing SIMD to JavaScript
by figglesonrails on Wednesday June 11, 2014 @12:07PM
(#7878732)
OK, it's not that HSA isn't useful, it's that coordination between the CPU and GPU is still stupidly hard and has a lot of CPU-side overhead, making it impractical for small workloads. The problem is that a large number of small workloads still can't be done by a GPU. I'm seriously doubting the limits of "coherent memory access" -- unless the GPU can snoop into the CPU's cache (or the GPU/CPU share L1 cache -- eeek), then you will still need cache flushes and fences. Let's hope that "HSA" is a lot lower overhead than current CPU/GPU combos from AMD/Intel.